{ "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge-public-template-registry.v1", "record_schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "status": "governed_public_templates_not_evidence_or_canonical_approval", "living_source_version": "YLS-2026.09.05.3", "derivation": { "rule": "Preserve the seven existing application architectures exactly while unifying only their domain IDs and attaching reviewed Living Source locators.", "application_architecture_source": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains", "project_registry_source": "atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json", "canonical_context_policy": "A canonical locator supplies context and governance only. It does not convert an application template into a canonical claim or evidence record." }, "authority_boundary": "These are public reusable templates, not private executions. Template presence, project mapping, or source linkage establishes neither evidence, successful action, canonical approval, nor proof of Y-Theory.", "domain_order": [ "teaching", "formal-research", "quran-audit", "agent-continuity", "community-food", "community-os", "runtime-r-and-d" ], "templates": [ { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-teaching", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "teaching", "title": "Teaching", "proposition": "A relational sequence may improve comprehension without asking learners to accept the whole framework.", "action": "Teach one concept, compare understanding before and after, and record confusion rather than smoothing it away.", "boundary": "Improved teaching does not prove the ontology.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=teaching]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/10_PROJECTS.md#12-y-theory-teacher", "role": "Canonical project context", "authority": "canonical_context" }, { "locator": "atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-011", "role": "Exact reviewed project registry match", "authority": "project_registry" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "resolved_exact", "project_ids": ["PRJ-011"], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-011"], "reason": "The registry names Y-Theory Teacher and explicitly gives progressive teaching as its purpose." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture names a teaching domain, not an accountable acting identity.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No operational teaching scale is fixed in the architecture.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Learners are mentioned, but no bounded beneficiary population is defined.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture does not operationally define variables.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Transfer, explanation quality, retained distinctions, and correction rate.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=teaching].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A before-and-after comparison is requested, but no baseline procedure or value is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No rival teaching explanation is enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Measures are named without a threshold for success.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No operational failure threshold is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no execution evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No cost model is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No stop rule is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private instance owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No instance-specific return destination is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private teaching instance only; it certifies no outcome and changes no canonical source." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-formal-research", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "formal-research", "title": "Formal research", "proposition": "One claim can be isolated from the wider narrative and made genuinely falsifiable.", "action": "Freeze premises, variables, rival explanations, data, stop rules, and the result that would count as zero.", "boundary": "One supported claim does not prove every domain bridge.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=research]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/11_METHOD.md#6-the-zero-to-one-challenge-protocol", "role": "Canonical method context", "authority": "canonical_context" }, { "locator": "canonical/10_PROJECTS.md#18-scientific-and-cross-domain-validation", "role": "Canonical research-path context", "authority": "canonical_context" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "review_required", "project_ids": [], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json"], "reason": "The registry contains multiple research-bearing projects, and the application architecture does not identify one project as its exact owner." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture does not name an accountable research identity.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No operational research scale is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No bounded beneficiary is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Variables must be frozen by a future instance; none are supplied by the template.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Discriminating prediction, reproducibility, error discovery, and useful nulls.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=research].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No concrete comparison baseline is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Rival explanations are required by the action but not enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No claim-specific success threshold is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A zero result must be defined by a future instance; it is not defined here.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no execution evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No cost model is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Stop rules are required by the action but no concrete rule is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No claim-specific closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private instance owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No instance-specific review or correction destination is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private research instance only; it is neither a preregistration nor a result." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-quran-audit", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "quran-audit", "title": "Qur’an structural audit", "proposition": "A frozen structural hypothesis can be compared transparently with immutable Arabic text.", "action": "Declare the text, annotation rules, rival analyses, nulls, exclusions, and independent review before computation.", "boundary": "Pattern fit does not prove revelation, decoded Divine intent, or physics.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=quran]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/07_FAITH.md#11-quranic-structural-and-computational-research", "role": "Canonical faith-audit context", "authority": "canonical_context" }, { "locator": "atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-015", "role": "Exact reviewed project registry match", "authority": "project_registry" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "resolved_exact", "project_ids": ["PRJ-015"], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-015"], "reason": "The registry uses the same Qur’an Structural Audit name and declares frozen claims, Arabic text, rivals, nulls, and review." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture names an audit domain, not an accountable audit identity.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No textual unit or corpus scale is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No bounded beneficiary is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Annotation rules are requested but no variables are operationally defined.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Annotation agreement, robustness to rivals, preregistered fit, null frequency, and reproducibility.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=quran].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No comparison baseline is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Rival analyses are required by the action but not enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No preregistered success threshold is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Nulls are required by the action but no failure threshold is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no audit evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No cost model is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No stop rule is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private audit owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No instance-specific independent-review return destination is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private audit instance only; source fit cannot certify revelation, Divine intent, physics, or the full theory." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-agent-continuity", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "agent-continuity", "title": "Agent continuity", "proposition": "A source hierarchy and return protocol may reduce context loss across human–agent work.", "action": "Recover the active relation field and any proposition-scoped correction, declare current status, make one bounded change, and leave a verified return record.", "boundary": "Continuity architecture does not make a software agent conscious.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=agents]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/12_LIVING_SOURCE.md#6-required-agent-behaviour", "role": "Canonical continuity-governance context", "authority": "canonical_context" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "review_required", "project_ids": [], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json"], "reason": "The architecture overlaps One Source / Knowledge DNA, Y-Theory Teacher, and AdvisoryMind, but it does not identify one registry project as its exact owner." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No specific human–agent work identity is named.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No handoff or project scale is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No bounded beneficiary is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture does not operationally define variables.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Contradiction rate, recovered decisions, handoff completeness, and time to trustworthy continuation.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=agents].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No comparison baseline is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No rival continuity process is enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Measures are named without a success threshold.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No operational failure threshold is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no handoff evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No cost model is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The bounded-change phrase does not specify an operational stop rule.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A verified return record is requested, but no closure criteria are supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private continuity owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The action requires a return record but does not declare its instance-specific destination.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private continuity instance only; it grants no autonomous authority, authorship, or consciousness." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-community-food", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "community-food", "title": "Community food", "proposition": "Food surplus and household need can be related without erasing dignity, local knowledge, or responsibility.", "action": "Map supply, need, timing, safety, transport, consent, and return one measurable intervention.", "boundary": "A service outcome validates the intervention, not all of Y-Theory.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=food]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/10_PROJECTS.md#15-community-intelligence-network--napam", "role": "Canonical community-application context; not an exact food-project assignment", "authority": "canonical_context" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "review_required", "project_ids": [], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json"], "reason": "The architecture could relate to Community Intelligence Network / NAPAM or SocialFork, but it does not identify one registry project as its exact owner." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No accountable intervention identity is named.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No locality, duration, or participant scale is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Household need is mentioned, but no bounded beneficiary population is defined.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Candidate factors are named but not operationally defined as variables.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Food diverted, households served, quality, repeat participation, cost, and waste displacement.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=food].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No current-state food baseline is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No rival intervention is enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Measures are named without a success threshold.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No operational harm or failure threshold is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no intervention evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Cost is named as a measure but no cost model or value is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No stop rule is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private intervention owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The action requests return but supplies no instance-specific destination.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private food intervention only; a later service outcome can validate only its bounded intervention." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-community-os", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "community-os", "title": "Community intelligence", "proposition": "Needs, offers, memory, action, verification, and correction can form a healthier local coordination loop.", "action": "Co-design one small Amherst/Cumberland loop with participants, consent, ownership, and stop rules.", "boundary": "A successful pilot does not prove a conscious collective Mind.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=community]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/08_COLLECTIVE.md#12-community-intelligence-network--napam", "role": "Canonical community-system context", "authority": "canonical_context" }, { "locator": "atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-014", "role": "Exact reviewed project registry match", "authority": "project_registry" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "resolved_exact", "project_ids": ["PRJ-014"], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-014"], "reason": "The registry names Community Intelligence Network / NAPAM and the same Amherst/Cumberland bounded loop." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No accountable pilot identity is named.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A small local loop is requested, but no participant count, duration, or operational boundary is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Participants are mentioned, but no bounded beneficiary group is defined.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "The architecture does not operationally define variables.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Need resolution, waste reduced, access improved, participant control, and unintended harm.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=community].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No current-state coordination baseline is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No rival coordination process is enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Measures are named without a success threshold.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Unintended harm is named as a measure but no failure threshold is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no pilot evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No cost model is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Stop rules are requested by the action but no concrete rule is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private pilot owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No instance-specific verification and correction destination is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private community pilot only; coordination success cannot certify a conscious collective Mind." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" }, { "schema": "y-theory.action-challenge.v1", "id": "AC-runtime-r-and-d", "record_kind": "public_template", "domain_id": "runtime-r-and-d", "title": "Runtime R&D", "proposition": "Contact, lag, residue, recurrence, and return can be implemented as measurable computational operators.", "action": "Run one controlled benchmark against a simpler baseline and preserve negative or rejected results.", "boundary": "Behavioral performance does not establish subjective consciousness.", "source_references": [ { "locator": "external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=runtime]", "role": "Exact existing application architecture", "authority": "application_architecture_input" }, { "locator": "canonical/09_DIGITAL.md#6-current-native-runtime-evidence", "role": "Canonical runtime-evidence context", "authority": "canonical_context" }, { "locator": "atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-008", "role": "Exact reviewed project registry match", "authority": "project_registry" } ], "project_mapping": { "state": "resolved_exact", "project_ids": ["PRJ-008"], "source_locators": ["atlas/PROJECT_REGISTRY.json#id=PRJ-008"], "reason": "The registry names Y Engine simulations and native body and explicitly lists contact, lag, residue, recurrence, and return." }, "identity": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No benchmarked runtime identity or version is named.", "source_locators": [] }, "scale": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No workload, dataset, or run scale is fixed.", "source_locators": [] }, "beneficiary": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No bounded beneficiary is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "variables": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Operators are named, but benchmark variables are not operationally defined.", "source_locators": [] }, "measure": { "state": "declared", "value": "Prediction, adaptation, stability, resource cost, failure modes, and replication.", "reason": null, "source_locators": ["external-input:y-theory-teacher-site/lib/site-content.ts#applicationDomains[id=runtime].measure"] }, "baseline": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A simpler baseline is required by the action but not specified.", "source_locators": [] }, "rivals": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No rival implementation is enumerated.", "source_locators": [] }, "success_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Measures are named without a success threshold.", "source_locators": [] }, "failure_criterion": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Negative and rejected results must be preserved, but no benchmark-specific failure threshold is supplied.", "source_locators": [] }, "evidence_locators": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A public template contains no benchmark evidence.", "source_locators": [] }, "cost": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "Resource cost is named as a measure but no cost model or value is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "stop_rule": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No run stop rule is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "closure": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No benchmark closure condition is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "owner": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "A reusable public template has no private benchmark owner.", "source_locators": [] }, "return_path": { "state": "undeclared", "value": null, "reason": "No instance-specific result and correction destination is declared.", "source_locators": [] }, "authority": { "state": "public_template_no_evidence_or_canonical_authority", "canonical_approval": false, "implies_evidence": false, "boundary": "This architecture can seed a private benchmark only; behavioral performance cannot establish subjective consciousness." }, "execution_state": "not_instantiated" } ] }