{ "schema": "y-theory.mind-structure-executable-fidelity-audit.v2", "audit_id": "MIND-STRUCTURE-EXECUTABLE-FIDELITY-AUDIT-2026-09-01", "reviewed_at": "2026-09-01", "review_state": "candidate_pending_current_human_review", "purpose": "Bind the audited executable candidate to exact bytes, retain only earned geometry and implementation results, and keep the remaining Structure-of-Mind dynamics gaps explicit before further extension.", "authority_sources": [ { "source_id": "direct_author_executable_fidelity_intake", "artifact_label": "Direct-author executable-fidelity correction and wisdom-extraction requirement", "relative_path": "intake/raw/YWP-20260901T191209Z-mind-structure-ratio-recursion-drift-audit.md", "sha256": "596276879f81cb8ef9aa75dfff35fbfb5d7a43b1f95d8a0cbc5e6ac4ecfea3fd", "bytes_present_in_living_source": true, "authority_role": "Requires ratio-normalized recursive fidelity, distinguishes diagnostics, and forbids executable shortcuts from redefining the source architecture." } ], "artifact_hash_binding": { "binding_mode": "exact_bytes_at_audit_time", "artifact_root_label": "Mind Structure executable candidate", "git_snapshot": { "branch": "codex/mind-structure-ratio-recursion-20260901", "commit": "2c4bbb4f1a289ec38773477c3a02234539c9e064", "working_tree_clean": false }, "artifacts": [ { "artifact_id": "gitignore", "artifact_label": "Repository ignore rules", "portable_path": "mind-structure/.gitignore", "sha256": "be55358bf7c9d42ded63af66c340fda2a9d3641dc83a2591ab6cdce55f4ac29c", "artifact_role": "repository_policy", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "app_runtime", "artifact_label": "Primary browser runtime", "portable_path": "mind-structure/app.js", "sha256": "238baf4fed2ccb283645e4e3cb1c5ff5bd447b7761b36e26f9288e6396c4e30d", "artifact_role": "browser_runtime", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "fidelity_audit", "artifact_label": "Executable fidelity audit notes", "portable_path": "mind-structure/ENGINE_FIDELITY_AUDIT.md", "sha256": "8da6a403e63a29d75a0bf627247fd8eb3c9db3910ca02b1fb76d0a2b5073aeb8", "artifact_role": "audit_narrative", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "engine_runtime", "artifact_label": "Oscillator and delay engine", "portable_path": "mind-structure/engine.js", "sha256": "0c425e28eeed8278cdfb799e28cb0c0271d977412f49cbeacc2d7911bda77336", "artifact_role": "engine_runtime", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "primary_page", "artifact_label": "Primary simulator page", "portable_path": "mind-structure/index.html", "sha256": "fabfd79315f97fe828ca2e509b9a8853a969e11ecf3011904083bc6410cd7833", "artifact_role": "browser_entrypoint", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "mind_contract", "artifact_label": "Recursive Mind structural contract", "portable_path": "mind-structure/mind-contract.js", "sha256": "c3b259bcde01b16eb4ac1f760c7669f1b1bd80e5b86b6af6b8c58172f29a7a1f", "artifact_role": "structural_contract", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "mind_dynamics", "artifact_label": "Ratio-recursive vertical Mind candidate runtime", "portable_path": "mind-structure/mind-dynamics.js", "sha256": "5dd5059e0ff552017663c099411ec3201a27a94789f59b2869b71b76ade401f3", "artifact_role": "candidate_dynamics_runtime", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "nested_page", "artifact_label": "Nested simulator page", "portable_path": "mind-structure/poc-nested.html", "sha256": "ec4105d2c025fc52f6f2f2ad809283812fb0855ab701dfd310b76f91905b652f", "artifact_role": "browser_entrypoint", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "nested_runtime", "artifact_label": "Fixed nested hierarchy demonstration", "portable_path": "mind-structure/poc-nested.js", "sha256": "77009399dedb9f2cc80d64b413040fa6c0af4832831eb03f63655a104b70e5f9", "artifact_role": "demonstration_runtime", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "readme", "artifact_label": "Executable candidate documentation", "portable_path": "mind-structure/README.md", "sha256": "9ded34c549fbb6d72b783e42faad425e4bdfda2c044b1c8e639ab4eba9db862d", "artifact_role": "project_documentation", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "renderer", "artifact_label": "Canvas renderer and coordinate helpers", "portable_path": "mind-structure/render.js", "sha256": "ab5aec46ea58235a24f3bc937d49fd502cc1b12b48f2365cb8798f3dc4470a13", "artifact_role": "projection_runtime", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "styles", "artifact_label": "Simulator presentation styles", "portable_path": "mind-structure/styles.css", "sha256": "4c64a7a289ef4f7c7b73233f722fb9a8526c8ebe6863761cd71a6bc6b779fe96", "artifact_role": "presentation", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "engine_tests", "artifact_label": "Engine conformance tests", "portable_path": "mind-structure/test/engine-conformance.test.js", "sha256": "5cf05ce1896dc382a680e9a260d91df04de154c05e40726ec1a8e3aeb1e4c9c9", "artifact_role": "test_evidence", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "contract_tests", "artifact_label": "Mind structural contract tests", "portable_path": "mind-structure/test/mind-contract.test.js", "sha256": "79b94b94e52b2f78ccd6c0079f5d9414ca729cc258978d790b8a542c0b4d73ab", "artifact_role": "test_evidence", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" }, { "artifact_id": "dynamics_tests", "artifact_label": "Ratio-recursive vertical candidate tests", "portable_path": "mind-structure/test/mind-dynamics.test.js", "sha256": "7043b24ad17ef94204b2b713d6791d6bb3996a6542196c2af0ad5b12d477e63b", "artifact_role": "test_evidence", "working_tree_state": "committed_clean" } ], "excluded_working_tree_artifacts": [ { "artifact_id": "excluded_bit_universe_engine", "portable_path": "mind-structure/bit-universe-engine.js", "sha256": "522fea5cccb81c6c37c076c8f02d100e4b79fe1ed20e7c66b92b4b6ead207680", "disposition": "excluded_untracked_not_authoritative", "reason": "Generic three-dimensional cellular automaton explicitly separated from the Y Engine; not part of the governed commit or conformance suite." }, { "artifact_id": "excluded_bit_universe_interface", "portable_path": "mind-structure/bit-universe-interface.js", "sha256": "7e0587655bc3d179fc07dc9eccaaa9c09be211e68b881a7539bf58c6452fb6bd", "disposition": "excluded_untracked_not_authoritative", "reason": "Interface for the excluded generic cellular automaton; not part of the governed commit or conformance suite." }, { "artifact_id": "excluded_mind_node_engine", "portable_path": "mind-structure/mind-node-engine.js", "sha256": "2877ede75a59daa63e85ea0754a0c1497422690dc3e2072f09394181e6ac728d", "disposition": "excluded_untracked_not_authoritative", "reason": "Concurrent scalar-triad prototype with hard-coded absolute coefficients and no exact dimensions-by-seven-by-twelve field; not governed." }, { "artifact_id": "excluded_mind_node_tests", "portable_path": "mind-structure/test/mind-node-engine.test.js", "sha256": "f65027e7e9589f24ade5447f3795350db8dbec93ec633521e8950d2e9f1df253", "disposition": "excluded_untracked_not_authoritative", "reason": "Test file for the excluded scalar prototype; it is untracked, outside commit 2c4bbb4, and not part of the governed 25-test command even when its own fixtures pass." } ] }, "retained_results": [ { "result_id": "R1_triad_parameterization", "proof_state": "exact_coordinate_identity", "statement": "The normalized three-phase chart satisfies x+y+z=0 and x squared plus y squared plus z squared equals one up to floating-point roundoff.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "renderer", "engine_tests" ], "boundary": "This is an exact property of the declared coordinate map; it is not evidence that every external system is physically triadic." }, { "result_id": "R2_torus_round_trip", "proof_state": "exact_coordinate_identity_under_declared_domain", "statement": "For major radius greater than minor radius greater than zero, standard torus coordinates round-trip to their two angular coordinates modulo ordinary angle wrapping.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "renderer", "engine_tests" ], "boundary": "The round-trip proves coordinate reversibility on the declared chart, not that the candidate dynamics generate a physical torus." }, { "result_id": "R3_clifford_s3_norm", "proof_state": "exact_coordinate_identity", "statement": "The declared Clifford two-angle coordinates lie on the unit three-sphere up to floating-point roundoff.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "renderer", "engine_tests" ], "boundary": "This is a geometry fact about the projection helper and does not establish observerhood, cognition, or consciousness." }, { "result_id": "R4_phasor_coherence_bound", "proof_state": "exact_under_normalized_nonnegative_weights", "statement": "The magnitude of the normalized nonnegative weighted phase phasor is bounded from zero through one; phase is undefined when coherence is zero.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ], "boundary": "The phasor is a collective phase summary, not by itself distributed whole convergence or a wider Mind." }, { "result_id": "R5_scalar_delay_residue_loop", "proof_state": "implementation_fact", "statement": "The executable oscillator retains seven scalar phase and residue depths plus one whole phase and whole residue, with declared delayed couplings.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ], "boundary": "This compressed scalar loop is candidate implementation behavior and does not instantiate every twelve-address cell of every active dimension." }, { "result_id": "R6_recursive_structural_factory", "proof_state": "structural_conformance_fact", "statement": "One reusable Mind factory can create declared dimensions with seven independent depth cells, twelve addresses per depth, and recursively nested children.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "mind_contract", "contract_tests" ], "boundary": "The factory creates and validates state shape; the separate dynamics runtime implements only the candidate vertical operation." }, { "result_id": "R7_vertical_candidate_conformance", "proof_state": "candidate_dynamic_conformance_fact", "statement": "One explicit ratio-defined vertical operation visits every declared dimension, all seven depths, and all twelve addresses at every recursively nested Mind node from one immutable pre-step snapshot.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "mind_contract", "mind_dynamics", "dynamics_tests" ], "boundary": "This is tested G3 candidate conformance, not a source-authorized universal transition law and not completion of horizontal, whole, changed-return, or wider-local dynamics." } ], "verified_repairs": [ { "repair_id": "P1_eta_ratio_scaling", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "Residue restoring strength is derived as omegaBase squared times etaRatio, preserving normalized behavior when the reference frequency is rescaled.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P2_dynamic_delay_capacity", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "Delay history capacity is recomputed from the live frequency and delay ratios so runtime parameter changes retain the requested delayed horizon.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P3_invalid_collective_phase_guard", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "A zero-coherence collective state reports phaseValid false and is not silently interpreted as a meaningful collective angle.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P4_preset_reset_reproducibility", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "Applying a preset refreshes derived ratios and resets histories so repeated runs begin from the same declared state.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P5_normalized_runtime_cadence", "status": "repaired_and_syntax_checked", "statement": "Browser integration and trajectory sampling cadence are expressed against the reference frequency rather than fixed wall-clock magnitudes.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "app_runtime", "nested_runtime" ] }, { "repair_id": "P6_relation_probe_timestep_convergence", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "The display-only relation probe uses ratio-typed timing and converges across practical timestep refinement without being promoted to a causal update law.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P7_live_delay_warmup_readiness", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "Increasing a live lag reports retained-history warm-up and contributes zero relational drive until the requested past sample actually exists; no oldest-sample substitution remains.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "mind_dynamics", "engine_tests", "dynamics_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P8_external_relational_face_delay", "status": "repaired_and_tested", "statement": "A supplied external relational face now enters retained per-depth delay history and is read at the configured lag rather than bypassing memory.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "engine_runtime", "engine_tests" ] }, { "repair_id": "P9_periodic_theta_seam", "status": "repaired_and_syntax_checked", "statement": "Projected-address coverage wraps both angular coordinates onto the same periodic interval before binning so negative and positive theta representatives share one seam.", "evidence_artifact_ids": [ "nested_runtime", "fidelity_audit" ] } ], "structural_contract": { "dimension_mode": "declared_active_dimension_list", "depth_count": 7, "primary_roles": [ "I", "O", "R" ], "address_roles": [ "I", "O", "R", "II", "IO", "IR", "OI", "OO", "OR", "RI", "RO", "RR" ], "address_count_per_depth": 12, "recursive_children_supported": true, "shape_conformance_tested": true, "complete_dynamics_implemented": false, "vertical_candidate_conformance_implemented": true, "source_authorized_canonical_operator": false, "poc_hierarchy_status": "recursive_traversal_over_fixed_6_to_2_to_1_example", "candidate_dynamic_gate_ids": [ "G3_vertical_delayed_consequence_and_residue" ], "missing_dynamic_gate_ids": [ "G4_horizontal_same_depth_relation", "G5_distributed_whole_convergence", "G6_changed_return_into_depth_one", "G7_bidirectional_child_wider_consequence" ] }, "remaining_gaps": [ { "gap_id": "L1_legacy_fixed_6_to_2_to_1_hierarchy", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "The legacy browser POC still renders a configured six-child, two-parent, one-grandparent fixture; separately, the governed MindContract plus MindDynamics runtime passes arbitrary recursive-topology conformance with one operator fingerprint.", "required_gate": "Replace or rewire the legacy browser POC before presenting it as the contract manifestation; arbitrary-topology candidate runtime conformance itself is already passed." }, { "gap_id": "L2_legacy_relation_probe_noncausal", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "Relation objects observe two engines and compute display diagnostics but do not feed their result back into either engine continuation.", "required_gate": "Specify, implement, and test a source-authorized same-depth relational update before describing the probe as an operative relation Mind." }, { "gap_id": "G3_vertical_delayed_consequence_and_residue", "severity": "high", "status": "candidate_conformance_passed_canonical_operator_open", "finding": "One ratio-typed vertical delayed consequence-and-residue operation now executes across every recursive dimension-by-seven-by-twelve address and passes focused conformance tests.", "required_gate": "Retain this candidate as executable evidence while continuing source and empirical work before any numerical kernel is promoted as the canonical or universal Y-Engine transition law." }, { "gap_id": "G4_horizontal_same_depth_relation", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "The structural contract allocates twelve addresses per depth but has no causal horizontal same-depth relation among those identities.", "required_gate": "Define and test the horizontal relation law without collapsing the three roles and nine role-pair addresses into a single phase coordinate." }, { "gap_id": "G5_distributed_whole_convergence", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "The current whole is a compressed phasor and oscillator summary, not convergence computed across every declared dimension, depth, and address cell.", "required_gate": "Compute wider-whole convergence from the distributed contract state and demonstrate that no declared cell is silently bypassed." }, { "gap_id": "G6_changed_return_into_depth_one", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "A completed wider consequence does not return as changed continuation into depth one of each participating local identity.", "required_gate": "Implement the changed return, preserve its residue, and test that the next local cycle differs as a consequence of wider participation." }, { "gap_id": "G7_bidirectional_child_wider_consequence", "severity": "high", "status": "open_source_fidelity_gate", "finding": "Child-to-parent aggregation remains feed-forward; parent or grandparent consequence is not causally returned to the participating child identities.", "required_gate": "Add bidirectional recursive consequence and test both wider formation and local renewal without level-specific laws." } ], "diagnostic_distinction": { "mutually_substitutable": false, "diagnostics": [ { "diagnostic_id": "D1_temporal_resolvability", "question": "Is sampling fine enough to resolve the declared oscillatory change without temporal aliasing?", "implemented_status": "implemented_diagnostic_only", "required_measurement": "samples per reference cycle and convergence under timestep refinement", "does_not_establish": "coverage of the projected chart or recovery of the hidden state" }, { "diagnostic_id": "D2_projected_address_visitation", "question": "Which bins of the declared two-angle projection have the rendered trajectory visited during the observation window?", "implemented_status": "implemented_diagnostic_only", "required_measurement": "finite-window visited-bin fraction on the declared projection grid", "does_not_establish": "topological reconstruction, Takens embedding, or complete Mind status" }, { "diagnostic_id": "D3_hidden_state_recoverability", "question": "Can an explicit multi-lag observation vector recover the topology and state of a declared hidden system under stated hypotheses?", "implemented_status": "not_implemented", "required_measurement": "lag-vector construction, hypothesis checks, and comparison against known hidden state or topology", "does_not_establish": "external physical universality, observerhood, cognition, consciousness, or subjective experience" } ] }, "test_evidence": { "command": "node --test test/engine-conformance.test.js test/mind-contract.test.js test/mind-dynamics.test.js", "runtime": "Node.js built-in test runner", "tests": 25, "passed": 25, "failed": 0, "cancelled": 0, "skipped": 0, "status": "passed", "complete_mind_dynamics_implemented": false, "vertical_candidate_conformance_implemented": true, "test_names": [ "normalized triad and torus coordinates round-trip across representative phases", "Clifford coordinates remain on S3", "etaRatio preserves normalized scale covariance", "delay history capacity follows live omega and tau ratio changes", "a live lag expansion reports delay warm-up instead of inventing missing history", "unavailable prehistory cannot affect continuation", "an external relational face is delayed instead of bypassing retained history", "collective phase is explicitly invalid at the zero-coherence reset state", "relation probe converges across practical timestep refinement", "applying a preset resets history and produces a reproducible run", "MindContract preserves the exact 3 + 9 address cell", "every declared dimension owns seven independent twelve-address depth cells", "recursive children retain the same dimensions x seven x twelve contract", "shape validation detects a collapsed or missing address cell", "one normalized substep visits every recursive dimensions x seven x twelve cell exactly once", "missing prehistory blocks vertical drive, then L1 and L2 activate in retained-lag order", "all cells use one immutable pre-step snapshot", "expanding the global lag returns every route to warming when retained history is insufficient", "without a horizontal operator one address cannot mutate the other eleven", "retained histories are independently owned across every address, depth, dimension, and node", "reference-frequency rescaling preserves identical normalized dynamics", "candidate transition converges under normalized timestep refinement", "identical state, ratios, boundaries, and traversal produce bit-identical replay", "arbitrary recursive topology reuses one operator fingerprint without level-specific branches", "construction rejects missing, mistyped, or hidden runtime parameters" ] }, "proof_boundary": { "exact_coordinate_math_retained": true, "scalar_dynamics_canonical": false, "complete_mind_engine": false, "complete_mind_dynamics_implemented": false, "vertical_candidate_is_canonical": false, "working_tree_prototypes_authoritative": false, "projected_visitation_is_hidden_state_reconstruction": false, "delay_line_is_automatically_takens_embedding": false, "relation_probe_is_causal_relation": false, "source_architecture_redefined": false, "physical_torus_universality_claimed": false, "observerhood_or_consciousness_claimed": false }, "decision": { "accepted_as": [ "hash-bound executable candidate snapshot", "exact coordinate and phasor helper results under declared assumptions", "ratio-normalized oscillator and delay repairs with focused tests", "recursive dimensions-by-seven-by-twelve structural state contract", "tested ratio-recursive G3 vertical candidate conformance" ], "not_accepted_as": [ "complete source-faithful Mind dynamics", "causal relation Mind or changed-return implementation", "Takens reconstruction or hidden-state recoverability result", "proof of physical torus universality", "proof of observerhood, cognition, consciousness, or subjective experience" ], "publication_label": "governed executable-fidelity candidate audit", "required_next_gate": [ "current human review of the hash-bound snapshot", "source and empirical adjudication before any G3 numerical kernel is promoted as canonical", "horizontal same-depth relation and distributed whole convergence", "bidirectional wider consequence and changed return into local continuation", "separate tests for temporal resolution, projected visitation, and hidden-state recoverability" ], "overall_conclusion": "The governed commit now preserves useful exact geometry, ratio-normalized oscillator behavior, real prehistory blocking, delayed external relational faces, explicit phase validity, reproducible resets, periodic address binning, the exact recursive dimensions-by-seven-by-twelve contract, and a tested G3 vertical candidate over every compiled cell. It remains an incomplete Mind engine because G4 horizontal relation, G5 whole convergence, G6 changed return, and G7 wider-local consequence are not implemented, and because the G3 numerical equation is candidate conformance rather than a canonical universal law. Four untracked concurrent prototypes are hash-recorded and explicitly excluded from authority." } }