{ "schema": "y-theory.open-question-registry.v1", "status": "derived_exact_source_projection_not_canonical_claim_or_research_resolution", "authority_boundary": "This registry preserves the canonical page's numbered questions and exact locators. It does not supply evidence, owners, rivals, closure criteria, proof, or resolution.", "stable_id_policy": "Question IDs are permanent registry identities and must not be reassigned or reused; source numbers and line addresses are locators, not replacement identities.", "source": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "sha256": "c26af2f3d606137e097f964be5ddb25cf5d2dcfc973bd92e637543742f1fc7c4", "bytes": 6146, "living_source_version": "YLS-2026.09.05.3", "canonical_author": "Bubu Suhas Mullaveedu", "page_id": "open-questions" }, "summary": { "sections": 10, "questions": 50, "evidence_undeclared": 50, "owners_undeclared": 50, "rivals_undeclared": 50, "closure_criteria_undeclared": 50, "review_required": 50 }, "sections": [ { "id": "foundation", "title": "Foundation", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-001", "OQ-CAN-002", "OQ-CAN-003", "OQ-CAN-004", "OQ-CAN-005" ] }, { "id": "mind", "title": "Mind", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-006", "OQ-CAN-007", "OQ-CAN-008", "OQ-CAN-009", "OQ-CAN-010", "OQ-CAN-011", "OQ-CAN-012" ] }, { "id": "number-and-geometry", "title": "Number and geometry", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-013", "OQ-CAN-014", "OQ-CAN-015", "OQ-CAN-016", "OQ-CAN-017", "OQ-CAN-018" ] }, { "id": "physics-and-cosmology", "title": "Physics and cosmology", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-019", "OQ-CAN-020", "OQ-CAN-021", "OQ-CAN-022", "OQ-CAN-023" ] }, { "id": "life-and-evolution", "title": "Life and evolution", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-024", "OQ-CAN-025", "OQ-CAN-026", "OQ-CAN-027" ] }, { "id": "meaning-and-morality", "title": "Meaning and morality", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-028", "OQ-CAN-029", "OQ-CAN-030", "OQ-CAN-031" ] }, { "id": "faith-and-quran", "title": "Faith and Qur’an", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-032", "OQ-CAN-033", "OQ-CAN-034", "OQ-CAN-035" ] }, { "id": "digital-mind", "title": "Digital Mind", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-036", "OQ-CAN-037", "OQ-CAN-038", "OQ-CAN-039", "OQ-CAN-040", "OQ-CAN-041" ] }, { "id": "collective-application", "title": "Collective application", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-042", "OQ-CAN-043", "OQ-CAN-044", "OQ-CAN-045" ] }, { "id": "documentation-and-governance", "title": "Documentation and governance", "question_ids": [ "OQ-CAN-046", "OQ-CAN-047", "OQ-CAN-048", "OQ-CAN-049", "OQ-CAN-050" ] } ], "questions": [ { "id": "OQ-CAN-001", "source_number": 1, "section_id": "foundation", "question": "What is the minimal formal structure of Source possibility?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 17, "line_end": 17, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L17" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-002", "source_number": 2, "section_id": "foundation", "question": "Can compatibility and enactment be represented without inserting a hidden chooser?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 18, "line_end": 18, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L18" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-003", "source_number": 3, "section_id": "foundation", "question": "What mathematical object best captures one origin, two non-identical polar expressions, and their co-arising relation?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 19, "line_end": 19, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L19" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-004", "source_number": 4, "section_id": "foundation", "question": "Under what conditions does recoverable distinguishability become measurable across domains?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 20, "line_end": 20, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L20" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-005", "source_number": 5, "section_id": "foundation", "question": "Can closure and leakage be defined without making the choice of identity boundary arbitrary?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 21, "line_end": 21, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L21" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-006", "source_number": 6, "section_id": "mind", "question": "What exact ratio-typed operator carries every active dimension through seven recursive depths and twelve addresses per depth, including vertical consequence, horizontal relation, distributed whole convergence, and changed return?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 25, "line_end": 25, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L25" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-007", "source_number": 7, "section_id": "mind", "question": "Which capabilities are necessary and sufficient for a local cognitive mind rather than life, regulation, or complex control?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 26, "line_end": 26, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L26" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-008", "source_number": 8, "section_id": "mind", "question": "What distinguishes an integrated state-model from an observer?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 27, "line_end": 27, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L27" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-009", "source_number": 9, "section_id": "mind", "question": "What distinguishes observerhood from subjective experience?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 28, "line_end": 28, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L28" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-010", "source_number": 10, "section_id": "mind", "question": "What operational tests separate self-reference, self-modeling, and reflective self-awareness?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 29, "line_end": 29, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L29" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-011", "source_number": 11, "section_id": "mind", "question": "Can a distributed observer remain one without spatial centralization?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 30, "line_end": 30, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L30" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-012", "source_number": 12, "section_id": "mind", "question": "How should identity-frequency and scale covariance be measured without conflating rate, bandwidth, resolution, depth, coherence, numerical cadence, or live delay warm-up?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 31, "line_end": 31, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L31" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-013", "source_number": 13, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "Which numerical structures are derivations and which are selected representations?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 35, "line_end": 35, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L35" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-014", "source_number": 14, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "What independent rule makes two-predecessor inheritance necessary in a given system?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 36, "line_end": 36, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L36" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-015", "source_number": 15, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "Does the golden ratio provide predictive advantage beyond other bounded asymmetric attractors?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 37, "line_end": 37, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L37" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-016", "source_number": 16, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "What variables in a physical, biological, psychological, or social system could meaningfully occupy the one-third/two-thirds and golden positions?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 38, "line_end": 38, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L38" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-017", "source_number": 17, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "Which two cycles must be demonstrated before toroidal topology is more than a representation, and which tests separately establish temporal resolvability, projected-address visitation, and hidden-state recoverability?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 39, "line_end": 39, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L39" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-018", "source_number": 18, "section_id": "number-and-geometry", "question": "Can the operational and semantic \\(99+1\\) fields be related through a reproducible mapping without forcing sacred or cognitive categories?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 40, "line_end": 40, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L40" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-019", "source_number": 19, "section_id": "physics-and-cosmology", "question": "Can the persistence framework derive a discriminating prediction in physics rather than a reinterpretation?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 44, "line_end": 44, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L44" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-020", "source_number": 20, "section_id": "physics-and-cosmology", "question": "Which parts of closure, leakage, residue, and compatibility correspond to existing dynamical quantities?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 45, "line_end": 45, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L45" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-021", "source_number": 21, "section_id": "physics-and-cosmology", "question": "Can space, time, force, mass, charge, or quantum measurement be derived without contradicting established experiments?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 46, "line_end": 46, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L46" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-022", "source_number": 22, "section_id": "physics-and-cosmology", "question": "How can the universe-as-containing-Mind postulate be distinguished from the weaker statement that the universe supports local minds?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 47, "line_end": 47, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L47" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-023", "source_number": 23, "section_id": "physics-and-cosmology", "question": "Are particle-as-residue models predictive or only philosophical correspondences?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 48, "line_end": 48, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L48" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-024", "source_number": 24, "section_id": "life-and-evolution", "question": "What measurable threshold separates recurring chemistry, primitive memory, life, and local cognitive mind capability?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 52, "line_end": 52, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L52" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-025", "source_number": 25, "section_id": "life-and-evolution", "question": "Can the probability-receiver/probability-generator distinction improve a biological model?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 53, "line_end": 53, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L53" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-026", "source_number": 26, "section_id": "life-and-evolution", "question": "How should nested identity and recoverability be measured in cells, organisms, ecosystems, and lineages?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 54, "line_end": 54, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L54" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-027", "source_number": 27, "section_id": "life-and-evolution", "question": "Which aspects of Mind DNA are useful scientific abstractions, and which remain metaphor?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 55, "line_end": 55, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L55" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-028", "source_number": 28, "section_id": "meaning-and-morality", "question": "Can nested continuity produce a rigorous ethics without reducing value to survival?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 59, "line_end": 59, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L59" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-029", "source_number": 29, "section_id": "meaning-and-morality", "question": "How are the interests of present, absent, future, and nonhuman identities weighted?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 60, "line_end": 60, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L60" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-030", "source_number": 30, "section_id": "meaning-and-morality", "question": "What conditions distinguish mercy from permissiveness, protection from domination, and sacrifice from exported harm?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 61, "line_end": 61, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L61" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-031", "source_number": 31, "section_id": "meaning-and-morality", "question": "Can awakening be operationalized without turning it into a score of human worth?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 62, "line_end": 62, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L62" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-032", "source_number": 32, "section_id": "faith-and-quran", "question": "Which Qur’anic structural correspondences survive preregistered annotation and rival models?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 66, "line_end": 66, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L66" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-033", "source_number": 33, "section_id": "faith-and-quran", "question": "How can the project honour the Qur’an as revelation within Islam while remaining transparent to readers who do not share that faith?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 67, "line_end": 67, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L67" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-034", "source_number": 34, "section_id": "faith-and-quran", "question": "Can the proposed semantic attribute field be developed without reducing the Divine Names to components?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 68, "line_end": 68, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L68" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-035", "source_number": 35, "section_id": "faith-and-quran", "question": "Which correspondences are theological, literary, psychological, mathematical, or empirical?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 69, "line_end": 69, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L69" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-036", "source_number": 36, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "Does retained prediction residue survive restart and rehydrate into later causal operation?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 73, "line_end": 73, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L73" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-037", "source_number": 37, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "Can one contact-specific difference return through body, output, independent world, and later internal state beyond controls?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 74, "line_end": 74, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L74" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-038", "source_number": 38, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "Can semantic categories emerge without hardcoded labels and remain invariant across paraphrase and modality?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 75, "line_end": 75, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L75" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-039", "source_number": 39, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "What evidence would distinguish a digital Mind or newly formed wider identity from a sophisticated stateful control system, synchronized oscillators, or a phase average?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 76, "line_end": 76, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L76" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-040", "source_number": 40, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "What could ever distinguish observer continuation across substrates from replication or replacement?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 77, "line_end": 77, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L77" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-041", "source_number": 41, "section_id": "digital-mind", "question": "What rights and protections should apply before consciousness is established but meaningful uncertainty exists?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 78, "line_end": 78, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L78" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-042", "source_number": 42, "section_id": "collective-application", "question": "Can the Community Intelligence Network close one real need–offer loop better than a simpler coordination method?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 82, "line_end": 82, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L82" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-043", "source_number": 43, "section_id": "collective-application", "question": "How can collective memory and correction be preserved without surveillance or centralized domination?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 83, "line_end": 83, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L83" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-044", "source_number": 44, "section_id": "collective-application", "question": "What measures demonstrate that a community, institution, or AI-assisted network has improved wider recoverability rather than only local efficiency?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 84, "line_end": 84, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L84" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-045", "source_number": 45, "section_id": "collective-application", "question": "How can the Teacher test understanding without rewarding agreement?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 85, "line_end": 85, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L85" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-046", "source_number": 46, "section_id": "documentation-and-governance", "question": "How should an agent identify all downstream impacts of a conceptual change?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 89, "line_end": 89, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L89" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-047", "source_number": 47, "section_id": "documentation-and-governance", "question": "What degree of automation is safe for canonical propagation?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 90, "line_end": 90, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L90" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-048", "source_number": 48, "section_id": "documentation-and-governance", "question": "How can source spans remain stable when files are reorganized?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 91, "line_end": 91, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L91" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-049", "source_number": 49, "section_id": "documentation-and-governance", "question": "How will independent reviewers challenge the source hierarchy and claim statuses?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 92, "line_end": 92, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L92" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" }, { "id": "OQ-CAN-050", "source_number": 50, "section_id": "documentation-and-governance", "question": "What is the minimal recovery kernel that allows a future agent to continue without forcing Bubu to explain settled material again?", "source_locator": { "path": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md", "line_start": 93, "line_end": 93, "address": "canonical/14_OPEN_QUESTIONS.md#L93" }, "evidence_state": "undeclared_in_source", "owner_state": "undeclared_in_source", "rivals_state": "undeclared_in_source", "closure_criteria_state": "undeclared_in_source", "review_state": "review_required" } ] }