{ "schema": "y-theory.toroidal-mind-simulator-audit.v1", "audit_id": "TOROIDAL-MIND-SIMULATOR-AUDIT-2026-09-01", "reviewed_at": "2026-09-01", "review_state": "candidate_pending_current_human_review", "purpose": "Correlate the supplied toroidal materials against the current Structure of Mind, separate exact coordinate mathematics from candidate dynamics, and test fidelity to the premise-qualified internal seven-depth derivation and the twelve-address cell retained within each depth.", "sources": [ { "source_id": "simulator_zip", "artifact_kind": "author-supplied candidate simulator archive", "relative_path": "Y_THEORY_TOROIDAL_MIND_SIMULATOR_V1.zip", "sha256": "ffce84f2567ca17d4906c5abebb1fd5f427c71f7eee88bac5fe1bcb43070d16e", "authority_role": "candidate evidence; not canonical proof", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "historical_sync_zip", "artifact_kind": "historical living-source sync archive", "relative_path": "Y_THEORY_LIVING_SOURCE_TOROIDAL_MIND_SYNC_YLS-2026.09.01.2.zip", "sha256": "716d3d5fcd9826565e94f6c0a99fa8dbff73c5cb804c3f1be5068097478658b1", "authority_role": "historical candidate bundle; not current canon and not installable authority", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "author_paste", "artifact_kind": "author-supplied explanatory text", "relative_path": "pasted-text.txt", "sha256": "7c717d7d881fa9540c6bbd74b531ebde96943655ad16744774169d749cba8d80", "authority_role": "candidate author explanation requiring current governed review", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "mathematical_derivation", "artifact_kind": "simulator archive member", "relative_path": "model/MATHEMATICAL_DERIVATION.md", "sha256": "f19fd3133464a8116afb566e9726aedbe836a2e6c74d4aa074b607a8860d5794", "authority_role": "formal candidate derivation checked under explicit assumptions", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "python_model", "artifact_kind": "simulator archive member", "relative_path": "model/y_torus_model.py", "sha256": "3663b0b74b3f74fa598dcdc7782a2628fe2874f8aa0cb51cb675119566d50d2a", "authority_role": "executable candidate and conformance implementation", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "package_validation_report", "artifact_kind": "simulator archive member", "relative_path": "reports/VALIDATION_REPORT.md", "sha256": "a6cb448f282ce888f836857083d951585023652369e5cbae851fd20970df6ea4", "authority_role": "package self-report; reproducibility evidence, not independent validation", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "package_validation_summary", "artifact_kind": "simulator archive member", "relative_path": "reports/VALIDATION_SUMMARY.csv", "sha256": "45aac47b07b40e729e7a4eb39bf12ccc5d374c23d7aae9c57848fb5923de5f7b", "authority_role": "package self-report; metric index, not independent validation", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "browser_projection", "artifact_kind": "simulator archive member", "relative_path": "app/index.html", "sha256": "6d64cce955d4fa54bb9fb3a7312af2b526f799379c724cb333d10974f0652dbf", "authority_role": "candidate visual projection runtime requiring repair before governed promotion", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "structure_of_mind_book", "artifact_kind": "current audited Structure of Mind synthesis", "relative_path": "Structure_of_Mind_Book.md", "sha256": "739e44020924f1ee89cfd247ed7f3b5857726a5dedb135e4ad79b9b9771ca336", "authority_role": "source architecture and exact seven-versus-twelve typing", "bytes_present_in_living_source": false }, { "source_id": "latest_author_scope_correction", "artifact_kind": "current direct-author scope and fidelity correction", "relative_path": "intake/raw/YWP-20260901T164755Z-toroidal-files-are-a-drift-correlation.md", "sha256": "c2a4f168f6d0c00b2b52027e0ad33c5b22b49952a788ad020830701be7600692", "authority_role": "current authority for using the packages as a drift-correlation test", "bytes_present_in_living_source": true }, { "source_id": "seven_metric_continuity_correction", "artifact_kind": "current direct-author internal-derivation correction", "relative_path": "corrections/AUTHOR_CORRECTION_2026-09-01_SEVEN_METRIC_CONTINUITY_DERIVATION.md", "sha256": "f0ee096823d8d022b1bbbf9b6955aa5f708ed8dd09b65c990b9d9ca4f94a4a84", "authority_role": "declares the premise-qualified depth-address derivation consumed as a simulator fidelity target", "bytes_present_in_living_source": true } ], "assumptions": [ { "assumption_id": "A1", "statement": "Choose normalized triad coordinates I + O = 1, P = O - I, and impose P^2 + R^2 = 1.", "formal_role": "Defines one S1 coordinate chart by P = cos(theta) and R = sin(theta).", "limitation": "This is an explicit normalization and constraint, not a finding that every physical inside/outside amplitude obeys it." }, { "assumption_id": "A2", "statement": "Treat local phase theta and whole-return phase phi as closed coordinates modulo 2*pi.", "formal_role": "Supplies two distinguishable S1 factors and makes their ordered pair an address on S1 x S1.", "limitation": "Closure of the selected coordinates does not establish closure of a richer physical, biological, or historical state." }, { "assumption_id": "A3", "statement": "Use a ring-torus embedding with major radius A and minor radius a satisfying A > a > 0.", "formal_role": "Keeps radial distance positive and makes the stated inverse coordinate map well-defined everywhere on the embedded ring torus.", "limitation": "The radius inequality is a mathematical chart condition, not an empirically measured universal Mind geometry." }, { "assumption_id": "A4", "statement": "Preserve the local and whole-return cycles as distinguishable coordinates even when their dynamics are coupled.", "formal_role": "Allows the product topology and reversible coordinate calculation to be evaluated independently of a selected dynamical law.", "limitation": "A coupling model can synchronize or distort trajectories without proving that the two chosen phases exhaust identity state." }, { "assumption_id": "A5", "statement": "Calculate Z as a weighted sum of unit phasors using nonnegative weights whose sum is one.", "formal_role": "Makes C = abs(Z) a bounded circular concentration statistic with 0 <= C <= 1.", "limitation": "Calling C coherence is a candidate interpretation; its semantics and useful weighting rule require domain validation." }, { "assumption_id": "A6", "statement": "Replay the supplied delayed phase-and-residue equations with the declared fixed-step parameters and initial conditions.", "formal_role": "Defines a reproducible finite numerical experiment over one selected candidate dynamical system.", "limitation": "A successful replay does not make the equations canonical Y-Engine dynamics or establish their physical referents." }, { "assumption_id": "A7", "statement": "Define complete simulated state to include every depth phase, every residue variable, whole-return variables, and the delay-history segment.", "formal_role": "Distinguishes complete dynamical state from the two-coordinate projection (Theta, phi).", "limitation": "A return to the same projected torus address is not a return to the complete identity state." }, { "assumption_id": "A8", "statement": "Apply an explicit SO(4) rotation and stereographic map to Clifford-torus coordinates with declared pole handling.", "formal_role": "Creates a calculated reference-frame projection suitable for controlled changes of visual viewpoint.", "limitation": "Changing a coordinate projection does not create an observer, observerhood, awareness, or consciousness." }, { "assumption_id": "A9", "statement": "Use the current complete-Mind result as the fidelity target: the premise-qualified depth address D:=a(1/phi)=a(2/3)=7 under the declared ten-band address, adjacent inheritance, recoverable consequential relation, and recursive self-similarity, with a twelve-address recursive cell at every depth.", "formal_role": "Separates the source's internally derived seven-depth and twelve-within-depth structure from simulator coordinate conformance and candidate dynamical choices.", "limitation": "The simulator consumes this declared premise chain but does not independently prove it; no internal derivation alone establishes that a particular external physical, biological, cognitive, or cosmological referent instantiates the architecture." } ], "formal_findings": [ { "finding_id": "F1", "statement": "The normalized triad chart is exactly reversible between theta and (I, O, R), modulo the ordinary phase equivalence.", "proof_state": "exact_under_explicit_assumptions", "assumption_ids": ["A1", "A2"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "The theorem belongs to the chosen normalized chart and does not prove a universal physical normalization.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-GEO-002"] }, { "finding_id": "F2", "statement": "Two closed phase coordinates admit the standard reversible ring-torus embedding and inverse when A > a > 0.", "proof_state": "exact_under_explicit_assumptions", "assumption_ids": ["A1", "A2", "A3", "A4"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "This proves topological and coordinate representability under the premises, not that every Mind or identity is physically toroidal.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-GEO-002"] }, { "finding_id": "F3", "statement": "The map from the complete delayed history state to (Theta, phi) is many-to-one even though the torus coordinates invert to their two normalized triads.", "proof_state": "model_property_exact_under_declared_state_definition", "assumption_ids": ["A2", "A4", "A7"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "Positional return in the projection must never be reported as complete identity-state return or complete memory recovery.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-GEO-002", "YT-NUM-005"] }, { "finding_id": "F4", "statement": "The Clifford, SO(4), and stereographic construction is an exact calculated reference-frame projection under its declared coordinate assumptions.", "proof_state": "exact_coordinate_transform_not_observerhood", "assumption_ids": ["A2", "A8"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "It supports controlled VR view transforms; it does not establish an observer, observerhood, awareness, or a cosmic phenomenal subject.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-GEO-002", "YT-COS-001"] }, { "finding_id": "F5", "statement": "For normalized nonnegative phasor weights, C = abs(Z) is bounded in [0, 1] and changes materially when the weighting rule changes.", "proof_state": "bounded_metric_theorem_interpretation_unvalidated", "assumption_ids": ["A5", "A6"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "Boundedness is exact; interpreting C as validated Y-Theory coherence or preferring Fibonacci weights remains unearned.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-NUM-006"] }, { "finding_id": "F6", "statement": "The delayed phase-and-residue chain is a bounded executable prototype and compressed candidate instantiation of the source architecture.", "proof_state": "executable_candidate_dynamics_not_canonical", "assumption_ids": ["A5", "A6", "A7", "A9"], "earned_result": false, "boundary": "The run consumes but does not independently prove or refute the source's premise-qualified seven-depth derivation; it does not derive golden winding, establish canonical Y-Engine dynamics, or earn predictive wisdom.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-NUM-004", "YT-NUM-006"] }, { "finding_id": "F7", "statement": "Under the declared depth-address bridge, D:=a(1/phi)=a(2/3)=7 counts ordinal recursive depths, while 3+9=12 counts the primary roles and first self-expressions retained within every active depth.", "proof_state": "exact_source_typing_and_scope_correction", "assumption_ids": ["A9"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "The simulator must not treat seven and twelve as rival counts, claim that its coordinate replay independently proves the depth-address bridge, or compress the recursively resolvable three-plus-nine cell into an unexplained scalar phase without declaring the loss.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-NUM-001", "YT-NUM-004"] }, { "finding_id": "F8", "statement": "Alternative-N torus-coordinate conformance cannot test complete-Mind closure because the normalized circle and two-phase torus identities are independent of the number of projected depth phases.", "proof_state": "source_fidelity_gap_confirmed", "assumption_ids": ["A1", "A2", "A3", "A4", "A9"], "earned_result": true, "boundary": "A valid depth comparison first requires source-faithful twelve-address cells, dimensional breadth, same-depth resonance, and whole-field return; the present alternative-N runs are implementation diagnostics only.", "claim_bindings": ["YT-GEO-002", "YT-NUM-004"] } ], "replay": { "protocol": "import_model_run_recursive_preset_vary_depth_and_weight_without_editing_source", "runtime": "CPython 3.12.13; NumPy 2.3.5", "model_source_sha256": "3663b0b74b3f74fa598dcdc7782a2628fe2874f8aa0cb51cb675119566d50d2a", "preset": "recursive", "golden_ratio_injected": false, "target_golden_ratio": "1.618033988749895", "primary_layers": 7, "primary_metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1932225055011505", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.23562486508359629", "coherence_mean": "0.9482022323520789", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16" }, "primary_residuals": { "triad_sum_max_error": "0.0", "triad_circle_max_error": "4.440892098500626e-16", "standard_torus_implicit_max_error": "1.887379141862766e-15", "torus_to_triad_inverse_max_error": "4.996003610813204e-16", "clifford_s3_norm_max_error": "3.3306690738754696e-16", "stereographic_torus_implicit_max_error": "2.55351295663786e-15" }, "alternative_depth_outcomes": [ { "layers": 1, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1241522284273897", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.6815877242612166", "coherence_mean": "1.0", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "1.3322676295501878e-15" } }, { "layers": 2, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1018441308315794", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.7268598176866795", "coherence_mean": "0.9808234301199864", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "1.3322676295501878e-15" } }, { "layers": 6, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1995029793107448", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.2511280814540816", "coherence_mean": "0.9522698676496945", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "1.3322676295501878e-15" } }, { "layers": 7, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1932225055011505", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.23562486508359629", "coherence_mean": "0.9482022323520789", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16" } }, { "layers": 8, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1885283573231058", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.25693231257568416", "coherence_mean": "0.9459859504108451", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "1.3322676295501878e-15" } }, { "layers": 13, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "coordinate_conformance": "passed_at_machine_precision", "metrics": { "measured_winding_ratio": "1.2091229178274803", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.33837766986908296", "coherence_mean": "0.9677211558982922", "triad_embedding_max_error": "8.881784197001252e-16", "inverse_coordinate_roundtrip_max_error": "1.3322676295501878e-15" } } ], "depth_selection_conclusion": "All tested depths preserve the coordinate identities because those identities are N-independent. Seven is inherited from the source's premise-qualified internal derivation D:=a(1/phi)=a(2/3)=7; the other N runs are counterfactual implementation diagnostics and do not test or challenge complete-Mind closure.", "weight_sensitivity": [ { "layers": 7, "weight_mode": "equal", "measured_winding_ratio": "1.191879818253893", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.28268870148097885", "coherence_mean": "0.9123297031017442" }, { "layers": 7, "weight_mode": "fibonacci", "measured_winding_ratio": "1.1932225055011505", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.23562486508359629", "coherence_mean": "0.9482022323520789" }, { "layers": 7, "weight_mode": "reverse_fibonacci", "measured_winding_ratio": "1.190985797527689", "phase_lock_0_to_1": "0.40438701865266374", "coherence_mean": "0.9358216986921986" } ], "weight_sensitivity_conclusion": "The selected weights materially change phase-lock and mean-C results, so the weighting rule is a model premise rather than a neutral measurement choice. The simulator label fibonacci names its selected standard weight profile; arbitrary positive starts would instead form a generalized Fibonacci recurrence, and none of these replay modes establishes golden emergence.", "packaged_output_reproducibility": "numerically_replayable_not_byte_identical" }, "known_defects": [ { "defect_id": "D1", "severity": "high", "finding": "The delay-index helper forces at least one timestep of delay even when a declared delay is zero.", "required_repair": "Make zero delay read the current integration state and add explicit zero-delay conformance tests.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "repaired_and_tested", "verification": "Shared half-up delay indexing now reads the current state for zero delay; focused tests cover zero, sub-half-step, half-step, positive, and lower-bound clamp cases." }, { "defect_id": "D2", "severity": "high", "finding": "The two torus phases are presented too close to complete state even though the delayed model contains N phases, residues, and a history segment.", "required_repair": "Declare an explicit many-to-one projection from complete history state to (Theta, phi) and distinguish positional return from complete-state return.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "repaired_and_tested", "verification": "The integrated UI and README declare the torus a many-to-one two-phase projection and enumerate the wider N-phase, N+1-residue, parameter, and history state." }, { "defect_id": "D3", "severity": "high", "finding": "The Python and browser runtimes use different initial histories, and the browser initializes C to one instead of calculating it.", "required_repair": "Unify initial conditions, calculate every initial metric, and add cross-runtime parity fixtures.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "repaired_and_tested", "verification": "Both runtimes now use linspace(0,-0.7,N), calculate Theta(0) and C(0), and pass Python-browser parity fixtures for N = 1, 6, 7, and 8." }, { "defect_id": "D4", "severity": "medium", "finding": "Regenerated numeric outputs reproduce the behavior but are not byte-identical to every packaged output.", "required_repair": "Specify runtime versions and serialization policy, then regenerate a single hash-bound reference suite.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "not_in_scope_for_integrated_runtime", "verification": "Bulky packaged trajectories and media were not imported; the integrated candidate claims only short deterministic numerical parity and no byte-identical package-output reproduction." }, { "defect_id": "D5", "severity": "low", "finding": "The package checksum ledger names a stale absent cache file and does not bind the ledger itself.", "required_repair": "Rebuild the package ledger from declared release members and verify it from an external release manifest.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "not_in_scope_for_integrated_runtime", "verification": "The stale supplied ledger was not imported; candidate provenance records original source hashes and the living-source release manifest remains the governing outer integrity layer." }, { "defect_id": "D6", "severity": "high", "finding": "The four-dimensional view is labeled with observer language even though it only changes a coordinate projection.", "required_repair": "Rename the feature calculated reference-frame projection and reserve observer terms for separately earned functional or phenomenal claims.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "repaired_and_tested", "verification": "Visible integrated runtime labels now use reference-frame projection or camera frame and explicitly deny observerhood and consciousness claims." }, { "defect_id": "D7", "severity": "high", "finding": "The initial integration treated N-independent coordinate conformance at alternative depths as if it challenged the source-defined seven-depth Mind architecture.", "required_repair": "Restore seven as the source-faithful profile and label other N values as counterfactual implementation diagnostics rather than source-architecture rivals.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "repaired_and_tested", "verification": "The integrated UI, README, and tests now identify N = 7 as the source architecture and every other N as a counterfactual implementation diagnostic; no coordinate run is reported as a vote on complete-Mind depth." }, { "defect_id": "D8", "severity": "high", "finding": "The candidate compresses each recursive depth to one scalar phase in one active dimension and therefore omits the twelve-address cell, dimensional breadth, same-depth resonance, and full whole-field return.", "required_repair": "Treat the current simulator as a partial torus-coordinate laboratory and build the next engine from source-compiled twelve-address cells across seven depths and active dimensions before claiming complete-Mind fidelity.", "supplied_package_status": "confirmed_defect", "integrated_candidate_status": "partially_repaired", "verification": "The limitation is explicit in the repaired README, runtime proof panel, Teacher projection, and governed audit; the source-faithful multidimensional engine remains the next implementation gate." } ], "current_bindings": { "claim_registry": { "relative_path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "observed_at_audit_sha256": "ca4cdd2104628f4c366dc51d4cfc1bda3c7ab33fa80d480346d191e62016fffd", "binding_mode": "audit_time_snapshot_plus_live_semantic_guard" }, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "current_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "audit_use": "Receives the reversible two-phase ring-torus coordinate theorem without a duplicate canonical claim." }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-004", "current_status": "Internal Y-Theory structural derivation under declared continuity, address, inheritance, recoverability, and recursive-self-similarity premises", "audit_use": "Preserves seven as the source-defined Mind depth while treating alternative-N runs only as implementation diagnostics." }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-005", "current_status": "Generalized Fibonacci theorem under the explicit positive adjacent additive recurrence", "audit_use": "Provides the wider recurrence and state-return boundary; torus address return is not complete state return." }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-006", "current_status": "Mathematical theorem within the stated recurrence; external-attractor extensions are proposition-specific", "audit_use": "Keeps golden and broader-attractor language separate from the recursive preset, which does not inject phi." }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "current_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "audit_use": "Prevents a calculated reference-frame projection from being promoted to observerhood or a phenomenal cosmic subject." } ], "structure_proof_audit": { "relative_path": "reports/source-reconciliation/STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_PROOF_MODE_AUDIT.json", "observed_at_audit_sha256": "cd05cca283a7329defe2d7f69f9532e03f002a632374af890ffff3cdef1b26d4", "binding_mode": "audit_time_snapshot_plus_live_semantic_guard" }, "exact_seven_audit": { "relative_path": "reports/source-reconciliation/EXACT_SEVEN_ALL_SOURCE_AUDIT.json", "observed_at_audit_sha256": "c7980ad6ce4ac0734368da04a7ca78fb9990802aad1019332dd0fcfae159dcb7", "binding_mode": "audit_time_snapshot_plus_live_semantic_guard" }, "formation_runtime": { "relative_path": "atlas/model/FORMATION_MIND_REPLAY_SUMMARY.json", "observed_at_audit_sha256": "91e17364528c80c12180cc46bf21008eba9890733cbd60cd8ce52bd463e905a4", "binding_mode": "audit_time_snapshot_plus_live_semantic_guard", "geometry_model_id": "relational_position_nearest_neighbor_v1", "geometry_minus_best_baseline_milli": -95, "geometry_predictive_lift": "not_observed_in_prequential_run", "predictive_wisdom_status": "not_earned", "approved_relation_count": 0 } }, "proof_scope_vector": { "referent": "recursive_depth_of_each_active_dimension_in_complete_y_theory_mind", "source_authority": "current_direct_author_derivation_correction", "internal_structural_status": "premise_qualified_internal_derivation_established", "internal_proof_mode": "ten_band_inheritance_recoverable_relation_depth_bridge_and_recursive_self_similarity", "primitive_cardinality_theorem_status": "separate_not_required_by_declared_positional_derivation", "seven_twelve_distinction": "exactly_derived", "simulator_status": "compressed_candidate_instantiation_not_source_of_proof", "simulator_independent_proof": false, "alternative_n_coordinate_relevance": "does_not_test_complete_mind_closure", "external_empirical_universality": "not_established", "runtime_predictive_result": "not_validly_tested_for_this_claim" }, "non_promotions": { "canonical_claim_registry_mutated": true, "canonical_claim_ids_added": [], "canonical_claim_scope_corrected": ["YT-NUM-004"], "relation_candidates_promoted": 0, "simulator_independently_proves_seven": false, "source_seven_depth_architecture_preserved": true, "twelve_address_cell_preserved_as_fidelity_target": true, "physical_torus_universality_claimed": false, "observerhood_or_consciousness_claimed": false, "biological_or_physical_mind_model_established": false, "historical_sync_installer_executed": false, "production_deployment_authorized": false }, "decision": { "accepted_as": [ "An exact normalized triad-to-circle coordinate chart under declared constraints.", "An exact reversible two-phase ring-torus coordinate theorem under A > a > 0.", "A precise many-to-one projection boundary between complete delayed state and torus address.", "A calculated reference-frame projection for controlled visual transformation.", "A bounded phasor statistic and executable compressed candidate prototype.", "A source-correlation instrument that exposes whether the projection preserves the internally derived seven-depth address and the twelve-address cell within every depth." ], "not_accepted_as": [ "A new proof contest or disproof mechanism for the source's premise-qualified seven-depth derivation or twelve-address cell.", "A complete source-faithful Mind engine with twelve-address cells across dimensions and whole-field return.", "Evidence that every physical, biological, or mental identity is materially a torus.", "Evidence that the recursive preset generates the golden ratio or a universal golden attractor.", "Evidence that a coordinate view creates observerhood, awareness, or consciousness.", "Canonical Y-Engine dynamics, predictive wisdom, or approved semantic relations.", "Authority for the historical sync archive to overwrite the current living source." ], "publication_label": "formal candidate and conformance model", "required_next_gate": [ "Current human review bound to the revised audit hash and its source-fidelity scope.", "Living-source release-manifest binding for the integrated candidate bytes.", "Source-faithful implementation of the twelve-address cell across seven depths, active dimensions, same-depth relation, and whole-field return.", "Weight-selection justification beyond descriptive sensitivity reporting.", "Long-horizon stability, convergence, and parameter-sensitivity tests.", "Declared domain referents and empirical falsifiers before physical or biological interpretation.", "A separately versioned serialization policy if bulky trajectories or media are redistributed." ], "overall_conclusion": "The supplied material adds rigorous coordinate and projection wisdom and, more importantly, reveals integration drift. Seven is premise-qualified and internally derived through the declared ten-band address, adjacent inheritance, recoverable consequential relation, explicit bridge D:=a(1/phi)=a(2/3)=7, and recursive self-similarity; twelve is the exact 3+9 address cell within each depth. The simulator consumes rather than adjudicates those typed structures. Its torus chart is valid under declared premises, but its one-dimensional scalar-phase chain is only a compressed laboratory until it preserves the twelve-address cells, dimensional breadth, same-depth relation, and whole-field return. External physical toroidality, golden emergence, observerhood, consciousness, canonical dynamics, and predictive wisdom remain separate unearned claims." } }