{ "schema": "y-theory.wisdom-metadata-review-registry.v2", "status": "candidate_only_unapproved_metadata_review", "authority_boundary": { "canonical_registry_mutation_authorized": false, "automatic_proof_promotion_authorized": false, "automatic_guardrail_invention_authorized": false, "correction_application_authorized": false, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null }, "boundary": "This ledger identifies incomplete metadata and preserves current values. It is not an edit, proof upgrade, guardrail, correction application, or canonical approval of WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv." }, "source_registry": { "path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "byte_count": 177291, "encoding": "utf-8-sig", "row_count": 364, "columns": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "normalized_status", "domain", "public_page", "related_claim_ids", "source", "guardrail" ] }, "evidence_sources": { "raw_wisdom_registry": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "record_count": 344 }, "canonical_claim_registry": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "record_count": 69 }, "source_inventory": { "path": "atlas/SOURCE_INVENTORY.json", "sha256": "0a8ecabf3f140de56987e2b34a18fa91bb75fb523e90bba4ad9bf37cc3595577", "record_count": 1610 }, "manual_visual_review": { "path": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md", "sha256": "6b29b121e5f9f5ab9b1430a31f9fa8b6a90d69eead3d70de11ae209891cd2f7b", "record_count": 8 } }, "selection_contract": { "proof_gap_rule": "Select when proof_status is blank after trimming or equals UNDECLARED case-insensitively after trimming.", "guardrail_gap_rule": "Select when guardrail is blank after trimming.", "union_rule": "Include every source row matching either gap rule exactly once, preserving CSV record order.", "proposal_rule": "Preserve nonblank current values without change; leave missing values null with an explicit review question." }, "proposition_scoped_correction_context": { "id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "captured_at_utc": "2026-09-01T13:30:02Z", "type": "direct_author_correction_relational_coherence_authority_and_proof_modes", "status": "captured_as_latest_author_source_reconciliation_correction", "raw_path": "intake/raw/YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority.md", "raw_sha256": "43d4cee5121e524bea2fb43a1739abee78ced9103677f2f9f124c826137feb08", "proof_boundary": "Relational coherence and internal derivation do not automatically establish an external empirical fact, independent replication, observerhood, consciousness, or predictive success. Date and duplicate copies do not establish authority or independent support.", "selection_rule": "configured_relational_coherence_correction_by_capture_id_not_recency" }, "gap_reconciliation": { "source_rows": 364, "original_proof_status_blank": 18, "original_proof_status_undeclared": 0, "original_proof_status_gap_total": 18, "guardrail_blank": 152, "proof_and_guardrail_overlap": 18, "affected_union": 152, "unaffected_rows": 212, "normalized_status_blank_within_affected": 0 }, "historical_visual_review": { "historical_required": 8, "completed": 8, "outstanding": 0, "new_independent_canonical_wisdom_approved": 0, "records": [ { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/deck-0_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/deck-0_contact.jpg", "sha256": "5af24651a1d99ffbc4fc4cb764adb5e9a06ea99678d2bac908789e319987ac0e", "byte_count": 883534, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=deck-0_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "Community Intelligence Network / NAPPAN: fragmented local capacities are connected through a community platform; events, contribution, guidance, incentives, and a prosperity cycle form repeatable community workflows.", "metadata_disposition": "Application context retained. No new primitive theory claim.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-001", "YT-COL-002", "YT-COL-003", "YT-PROJ-002" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-1_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-1_contact.jpg", "sha256": "5d9791514118b4375b47db3e8ec842487d0142eb3d73b9fbde5f4631490060d3", "byte_count": 363775, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-1_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "The food pilot is treated as the first door into a wider network; an existing local base can be reused across domains and institutions without repeating the full initial investment.", "metadata_disposition": "Application context retained. Supports reuse, nested growth, and guided expansion, but does not prove scale invariance.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-001", "YT-PROJ-002", "YT-ETH-001" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-2_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-2_contact.jpg", "sha256": "52d9bd3944b7c15fa88be410dfc7825784f1b62bebdde3d5a87e4998d9c8a35e", "byte_count": 431927, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-2_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "Community empowerment is distinguished from surveillance and centralized control. Decentralized connection, feedback, adaptation, and human participation are presented as resilience conditions.", "metadata_disposition": "Application and governance guardrail retained. Claims about resilience require domain evidence.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-002", "YT-ETH-001", "YT-ETH-003", "YT-METHOD-004" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-3_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-3_contact.jpg", "sha256": "35d2245e8202de60d0a1447bf96cfa0095a7248a72a61a2e814a5e2c132ea2a3", "byte_count": 637486, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-3_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "A community interaction engine generates workflows that move through attention, question, discussion, opportunity, project, event, action, feedback, and renewed coordination.", "metadata_disposition": "Application topology retained. This is a social workflow expression of the engine, not a new universal mechanism.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-001", "YT-COL-002", "YT-PROJ-002" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-4_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-4_contact.jpg", "sha256": "1228a01b85d9582a7a592dc17fbbb03df20cba0bbaa971ff71b671e5e7e92e0e", "byte_count": 441167, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-4_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "One participant can hold several roles while retaining one identity; dashboards organize resident, contributor, organizer, vendor, expert, and guide workflows.", "metadata_disposition": "Application architecture retained. Role multiplicity must not erase personhood, consent, or privacy.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-ID-003", "YT-COL-001", "YT-ETH-003", "YT-PROJ-002" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-5_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-5_contact.jpg", "sha256": "d2f6306654afe1c83200a7d77f76349c51211e94499a4c7fd92fa951eaa16171", "byte_count": 343813, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-5_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "Project Heaven describes a staged transition from competition toward cooperation and contribution, including faith and secular invitations and a non-monetary contribution economy.", "metadata_disposition": "Vision/application retained. Utopian outcomes, economic sufficiency, and spiritual claims remain proposals, not validated consequences.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-003", "YT-ETH-001", "YT-FAITH-003", "YT-PROJ-002" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-6_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck-6_contact.jpg", "sha256": "ae597abab9885e3ed38bb6580522b915c60c67dc337277f33d7c702204121484", "byte_count": 425574, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck-6_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "Explicit Y-Theory visual sequence: first relationship/loop; inside and outside; receiver gate; lag, leakage, and closure; repetition across scales; community loop; partnership; roadmap; cooperation; metacognition.", "metadata_disposition": "Theory visualization linked, not independent proof. The compression is covered by the core, Mind, collective, and method claim families.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-CORE-003", "YT-CORE-005", "YT-CORE-006", "YT-CORE-007", "YT-MIND-003", "YT-MIND-004", "YT-COL-001" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false }, { "source_id": "repo:knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck0_0_contact.jpg", "path": "knowledge-dna/Architecture_Notes/ppt_contact_sheets/Deck0_0_contact.jpg", "sha256": "e9ea5d305002f8e6efb2f1a5191ce866f31a6a59ae2bdd8dbe2cb732f854e73e", "byte_count": 263897, "review_source_locator": "reports/wisdom-coverage/MANUAL_VISUAL_REVIEW.md#source=Deck0_0_contact.jpg", "visible_contribution": "Early community guidance-network concept: people contribute needs and knowledge; experts and institutions validate; guidance returns through a recurring community loop.", "metadata_disposition": "Historical application precursor retained. Validation must remain distributed and appealable; network output is not truth by itself.", "related_claim_ids": [ "YT-COL-002", "YT-METHOD-003", "YT-PROJ-002" ], "review_state": "completed_visual_metadata_review_no_promotion", "independent_proof_supplied": false, "canonical_approval_granted": false } ], "boundary": "Direct inspection closes the eight historical image-review obligations. Each contact sheet contributes application or visualization metadata only; it supplies no independent proof, canonical metadata value, claim promotion, or canonical approval." }, "records": [ { "id": "WMR-W35-01", "review_ordinal": 1, "source_row_ordinal": 152, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-01", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-01", "name": "Model-Before-Message Law", "statement": "A system should not be advanced toward language or communication before it can model alternatives, predict consequence, and gate action.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-01", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 152, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-01", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 152, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-01, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-01" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-01 (Model-Before-Message Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-02", "review_ordinal": 2, "source_row_ordinal": 153, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-02", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-02", "name": "Two-Correction-Channel Law", "statement": "A mature mind needs empirical correction from the world and normative correction from source/purpose; neither can replace the other.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-02", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 153, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-02", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 153, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-02, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-02" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-02 (Two-Correction-Channel Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-03", "review_ordinal": 3, "source_row_ordinal": 154, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-03", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-03", "name": "Continuity-Substrate / Mind-Controller Distinction", "statement": "A recurrent recoverable body can be a substrate for mind without yet being a mind.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-03", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 154, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-03", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 154, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-03, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-03" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-03 (Continuity-Substrate / Mind-Controller Distinction) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-04", "review_ordinal": 4, "source_row_ordinal": 155, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-04", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-04", "name": "Internal Observer Law", "statement": "The observer that matters for mind must participate in prediction, mismatch, correction, and future modification inside the system.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-COL-001", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-04", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 155, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-04", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 155, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-04, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-04" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-04 (Internal Observer Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-05", "review_ordinal": 5, "source_row_ordinal": 156, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-05", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-05", "name": "Candidate Plurality Law", "statement": "Decision space requires more than one possible future under active comparison.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-002;YT-COL-001", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-05", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 156, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-002;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-05", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 156, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-05, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-05" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-05 (Candidate Plurality Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-06", "review_ordinal": 6, "source_row_ordinal": 157, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-06", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-06", "name": "Independent World Law", "statement": "A mind cannot prove prediction by reading consequences it or its observers wrote into its own body.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-06", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 157, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-06", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 157, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-06, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-06" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-06 (Independent World Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-07", "review_ordinal": 7, "source_row_ordinal": 158, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-07", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-07", "name": "Stakes-Before-Protection Law", "statement": "Protective intelligence can only be measured when action has finite cost, damage, and repair implications.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-07", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 158, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-07", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 158, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-07, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-07" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-07 (Stakes-Before-Protection Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-08", "review_ordinal": 8, "source_row_ordinal": 159, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-08", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-08", "name": "Source-After-Manifestation Law", "statement": "Source correspondence should be introduced after an anonymous manifested identity/world loop exists.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-08", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 159, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-08", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 159, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-08, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-08" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-08 (Source-After-Manifestation Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-09", "review_ordinal": 9, "source_row_ordinal": 160, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-09", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-09", "name": "Guidance-as-Evaluation Law", "statement": "Guidance should shape which future/action is acceptable and how errors are repaired, not simply increase retention.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-09", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 160, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-09", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 160, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-09, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-09" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-09 (Guidance-as-Evaluation Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-10", "review_ordinal": 10, "source_row_ordinal": 161, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-10", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-10", "name": "Laboratory-Is-Not-Mind Law", "statement": "An increasingly intelligent observer network can become the effective reasoning system while the simulated body remains simple.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-10", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 161, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-10", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 161, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-10, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-10" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-10 (Laboratory-Is-Not-Mind Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-11", "review_ordinal": 11, "source_row_ordinal": 162, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-11", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-11", "name": "Four-Plane Experimental Architecture", "statement": "Separate core mind, body/world, source/guidance, and lab harness so no plane can manufacture evidence for another.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-11", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 162, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-11", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 162, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-11, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-11" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-11 (Four-Plane Experimental Architecture) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-12", "review_ordinal": 12, "source_row_ordinal": 163, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-12", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-12", "name": "Branch-Reconciliation Law", "statement": "Competing implementation branches must be named by function, not reuse one version as if they were one phase.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-12", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 163, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-12", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 163, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-12, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-12" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-12 (Branch-Reconciliation Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-13", "review_ordinal": 13, "source_row_ordinal": 164, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-13", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-13", "name": "Phase-Maturity Separation", "statement": "Lab maturity, body continuity, agency, communication, language, morality, and consciousness are different progress axes.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-13", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 164, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-13", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 164, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-13, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-13" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-13 (Phase-Maturity Separation) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-14", "review_ordinal": 14, "source_row_ordinal": 165, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-14", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-14", "name": "Reference-Implementation-First Law", "statement": "A transparent CPU/sidecar reference can validate causal architecture before CUDA optimization.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-14", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 165, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-14", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 165, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-14, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-14" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-14 (Reference-Implementation-First Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-15", "review_ordinal": 15, "source_row_ordinal": 166, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-15", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-15", "name": "Core-Lens Firewall", "statement": "Cosmology, faith, torus, Fibonacci, DNA, and Root Matrix may guide hypotheses but cannot define core runtime variables without separate derivation.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-15", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 166, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-15", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 166, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-15, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-15" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-15 (Core-Lens Firewall) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-16", "review_ordinal": 16, "source_row_ordinal": 167, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-16", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-16", "name": "Mind-Birth Gate", "statement": "The minimum mind gate is model + candidate futures + action gating + consequence + prediction error + correction + improved continuity.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-003;YT-COL-001", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-16", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 167, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-003;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-16", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 167, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-16, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-16" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-16 (Mind-Birth Gate) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-17", "review_ordinal": 17, "source_row_ordinal": 168, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-17", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-17", "name": "Developmental Sequence Law", "statement": "The correct boot order is world/contact → retention → prediction → agency → internal observer → guidance → communication → social mind.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-17", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 168, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-17", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 168, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-17, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-17" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-17 (Developmental Sequence Law) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-W35-18", "review_ordinal": 18, "source_row_ordinal": 169, "source_wisdom_id": "W35-18", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "W35-18", "name": "Correspondence Needs Nulls", "statement": "Cross-scale similarity becomes evidence only when preregistered invariants outperform plausible alternative mappings.", "proof_status": "", "normalized_status": "Historical / status review required", "domain": "Experimental Mind Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-002", "source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=W35-18", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 169, "original_source_field": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-002", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=W35-18", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 169, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "blank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "Y_ENGINE_SOURCE_RESET_CROSS_AUDIT_V35/Y_ENGINE_NEW_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V35.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": true, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": true, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "Which governed original proof-status value is explicitly source-supported for W35-18, or should it remain undeclared?", "source_locators": [] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Historical / status review required", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=W35-18" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain W35-18 (Correspondence Needs Nulls) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_source_supported_original_value", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_MISSING", "NORMALIZED_STATUS_IS_NOT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS", "RELATED_CLAIM_STATUS_IS_CONTEXT_NOT_RECORD_PROOF", "RAW_REGISTRY_PROOF_STATUS_BLANK", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-001", "review_ordinal": 19, "source_row_ordinal": 198, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-001", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-001", "name": "core", "statement": "Source, engine, and manifestation must remain distinct: source supplies constraint/orientation, the engine transforms, and manifestation is the resulting state.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-006", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-001", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 198, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-006", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-001", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 198, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-001" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-001" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-001 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-002", "review_ordinal": 20, "source_row_ordinal": 199, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-002", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-002", "name": "core", "statement": "Existence is continuing distinguishability through ordered change, not passive presence or static duration.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-007", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-002", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 199, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-007", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-002", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 199, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-002" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-002" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-002 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-003", "review_ordinal": 21, "source_row_ordinal": 200, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-003", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-003", "name": "core", "statement": "Probability is structural tendency under constraint, not merely ignorance in an observer.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-003", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 200, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-003", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 200, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-003" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-003" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-003 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-004", "review_ordinal": 22, "source_row_ordinal": 201, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-004", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-004", "name": "core", "statement": "Noise is active exploration of possible configurations before reinforced closure; it is not nothingness or mere disorder.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-004", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 201, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-004", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 201, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-004" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-004" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-004 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-005", "review_ordinal": 23, "source_row_ordinal": 202, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-005", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-005", "name": "core", "statement": "Trace is the first carry-forward of difference; memory is retained constraint that changes future possibility.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-005", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 202, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-005", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 202, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-005" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-005" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-005 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-006", "review_ordinal": 24, "source_row_ordinal": 203, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-006", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-006", "name": "core", "statement": "Reinforcement alone does not create persistence; it must be balanced by leakage, damping, regulation, and closure.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-006", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 203, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-006", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 203, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-006" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-006" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-006 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-007", "review_ordinal": 25, "source_row_ordinal": 204, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-007", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-007", "name": "core", "statement": "Leakage is both threat and regulator; it tests coherence and prevents unlimited runaway closure.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-007", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 204, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-007", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 204, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-007" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-007" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-007 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-008", "review_ordinal": 26, "source_row_ordinal": 205, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-008", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-008", "name": "core", "statement": "Lag is the interval in which prior structure remains active during response; it is essential for memory-bearing and mind-like identity but should not be overstated as necessary for every simple persistence.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-008", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 205, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-008", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 205, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-008" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-008" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-008 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-009", "review_ordinal": 27, "source_row_ordinal": 206, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-009", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-009", "name": "core", "statement": "Persistence, stability, and recoverability are separate: persistence continues now, stability remains bounded, recoverability can leave a band and return before identity is lost.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-009", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 206, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-009", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 206, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-009" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-009" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-009 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-010", "review_ordinal": 28, "source_row_ordinal": 207, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-010", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-010", "name": "identity", "statement": "Identity birth and identity survival are different problems. Birth requires a protected persistence window; survival requires a recovery basin under perturbation.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Identity, Memory & Recoverability", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-010", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 207, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-002", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-010", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 207, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-002", "claim_title": "Update recursion and depth recursion", "claim_status": "Canonical structural distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Repeated updates do not automatically create a wider identity. The wider relation must acquire its own consequence, return, and continuity.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-010" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-010" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-010 (identity) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-011", "review_ordinal": 29, "source_row_ordinal": 208, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-011", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-011", "name": "identity", "statement": "Identity is trajectory or pattern-class continuity, not exact state copying or fixed material sameness.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Identity, Memory & Recoverability", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-001;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-011", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 208, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-001;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-002", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-011", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 208, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-002", "claim_title": "Update recursion and depth recursion", "claim_status": "Canonical structural distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Repeated updates do not automatically create a wider identity. The wider relation must acquire its own consequence, return, and continuity.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-011" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-011" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-011 (identity) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-012", "review_ordinal": 30, "source_row_ordinal": 209, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-012", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-012", "name": "identity", "statement": "Recursive viability, identity basins, regeneration, and basin hierarchy explain how nested identities recover at different scales.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Identity, Memory & Recoverability", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-012", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 209, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-002", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-012", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 209, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-002", "claim_title": "Update recursion and depth recursion", "claim_status": "Canonical structural distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Repeated updates do not automatically create a wider identity. The wider relation must acquire its own consequence, return, and continuity.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-012" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-012" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-012 (identity) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-013", "review_ordinal": 31, "source_row_ordinal": 210, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-013", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-013", "name": "core", "statement": "Pattern dependence and interaction can create novelty; unresolved residual may deform a model, form a motif, or branch into a new regime.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Reality, Existence & Y Engine", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-013", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 210, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-005;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-001", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-013", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 210, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-013" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-013" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-013 (core) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-015", "review_ordinal": 32, "source_row_ordinal": 212, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-015", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-015", "name": "method", "statement": "Contradiction should be preserved as layered knowledge until resolved; deletion hides either a real inconsistency or a boundary between levels.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-002;YT-PROJ-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-015", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 212, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-002;YT-PROJ-001", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-015", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 212, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-002", "claim_title": "Source hierarchy and supersession without erasure", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not silently merge propositions, count byte duplicates as independent support, or treat a filename, modification date, rhetorical polish, or source label as truth authority. Record conflict only after incompatibility remains under the same normalized subject and declared conditions.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "corrections/AUTHOR_CORRECTION_2026-09-01_RELATIONAL_COHERENCE_AUTHORITY.md", "governance/SOURCE_COHERENCE_AND_REPAIR_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-015" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-015" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-015 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-016", "review_ordinal": 33, "source_row_ordinal": 213, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-016", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-016", "name": "method", "statement": "A source book, corpus, or documentation substrate is memory; mind requires active attention, selection, interpretation, correction, and return.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-016", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 213, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-016", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 213, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-016" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-016" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-016 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-017", "review_ordinal": 34, "source_row_ordinal": 214, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-017", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-017", "name": "method", "statement": "The reader book, audit appendix, and implementation manual are different artifacts and should not be merged into one endless sequence.", "proof_status": "EDITORIAL_METHOD", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-017", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 214, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-017", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 214, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "EDITORIAL_METHOD", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-017" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-017" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-017 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-018", "review_ordinal": 35, "source_row_ordinal": 215, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-018", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-018", "name": "method", "statement": "Claims require explicit proof status: definition, source synthesis, formal derivation, correspondence, theological lens, implementation, watch evidence, hypothesis, or open question.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-018", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 215, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-018", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 215, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-018" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-018" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-018 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-019", "review_ordinal": 36, "source_row_ordinal": 216, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-019", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-019", "name": "physics", "statement": "Space should be introduced as an active relation/operator emerging from survivable degrees of freedom, not assumed as the first passive container.", "proof_status": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-CORE-006", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-019", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 216, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-CORE-006", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-019", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 216, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-019" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-019" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-019 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-020", "review_ordinal": 37, "source_row_ordinal": 217, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-020", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-020", "name": "physics", "statement": "Oscillation is structural recurrence; vibration is its spatial expression. Teaching vibration before oscillation reverses the derivation.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-GEO-003;YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-020", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 217, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-GEO-003;YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-002", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-020", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 217, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-003", "claim_title": "Geometry does not replace ontology", "claim_status": "Canonical method rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer physical shape, sacred necessity, or dimensional count from a convenient diagram.", "claim_sources": [ "THE_STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_CANONICAL_RESTART.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-020" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-020" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-020 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-021", "review_ordinal": 38, "source_row_ordinal": 218, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-021", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-021", "name": "physics", "statement": "Fields can be treated as modifications of compatibility and transition tendency, while this remains a formal interpretation requiring domain-specific derivation.", "proof_status": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-021", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 218, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-021", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 218, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-003", "claim_title": "Geometry does not replace ontology", "claim_status": "Canonical method rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer physical shape, sacred necessity, or dimensional count from a convenient diagram.", "claim_sources": [ "THE_STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_CANONICAL_RESTART.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-021" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-021" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-021 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-022", "review_ordinal": 39, "source_row_ordinal": 219, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-022", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-022", "name": "physics", "statement": "Physical laws and constants may be interpreted as stable closure-invariant relations, but the exact derivation and empirical sufficiency remain open.", "proof_status": "OPEN_FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Open question / hypothesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-022", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 219, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-022", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 219, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-003", "claim_title": "Geometry does not replace ontology", "claim_status": "Canonical method rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer physical shape, sacred necessity, or dimensional count from a convenient diagram.", "claim_sources": [ "THE_STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_CANONICAL_RESTART.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "OPEN_FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-022" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Open question / hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-022" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-022 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-023", "review_ordinal": 40, "source_row_ordinal": 220, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-023", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-023", "name": "physics", "statement": "Measurement at the physical layer is coupling, filtering, and persistence-dependent interaction; conscious observation is a later specialization.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-CORE-006", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-023", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 220, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-CORE-006", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-023", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 220, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-023" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-023" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-023 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-024", "review_ordinal": 41, "source_row_ordinal": 221, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-024", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-024", "name": "physics", "statement": "Dimensionality is survivable freedom of variation; specific claims about why three dimensions dominate require formal and physical tests.", "proof_status": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-CORE-006", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-024", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 221, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-CORE-006", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-024", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 221, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "FORMAL_HYPOTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-024" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Formal or mathematical hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-024" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-024 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-025", "review_ordinal": 42, "source_row_ordinal": 222, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-025", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-025", "name": "physics", "statement": "Toroids, spirals, seven layers, Fibonacci ratios, golden bands, and cosmic correspondences are observer lenses until independently derived and compared with alternatives.", "proof_status": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics & Cosmology", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-004;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-025", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 222, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-004;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-025", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 222, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-025" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-025" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-025 (physics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-026", "review_ordinal": 43, "source_row_ordinal": 223, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-026", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-026", "name": "mathematics", "statement": "The mathematical layer must distinguish proof, conservative skeleton, effective index, heuristic analogy, and open theorem.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Numbers, Mathematics & Geometry", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-NUM-005;YT-GEO-003;YT-NUM-006;YT-NUM-008", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-026", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 223, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-NUM-005;YT-GEO-003;YT-NUM-006;YT-NUM-008", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-026", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 223, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-005", "claim_title": "Fibonacci inheritance", "claim_status": "Generalized Fibonacci theorem under the explicit positive adjacent additive recurrence", "claim_guardrail": "Do not call every positive solution the standard Fibonacci sequence: arbitrary positive adjacent starts give generalized Fibonacci, while the equal-start pair gives the standard scaled sequence. Do not infer the recurrence from the number three, recursion in general, or residue without establishing the two-predecessor additive inheritance rule in the addressed system.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-003", "claim_title": "Geometry does not replace ontology", "claim_status": "Canonical method rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer physical shape, sacred necessity, or dimensional count from a convenient diagram.", "claim_sources": [ "THE_STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_CANONICAL_RESTART.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-006", "claim_title": "Golden complementary allocation", "claim_status": "Mathematical theorem within the stated recurrence; external-attractor extensions are proposition-specific", "claim_guardrail": "The theorem applies to the declared recurrence. Every physical, biological, cognitive, moral, or social extension must establish the recurrence, observables, tolerance, rival baseline, held-out prediction, and falsifier independently.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-008", "claim_title": "One-third/two-thirds continuity frame", "claim_status": "Exact equal-start adjacent-inheritance envelope plus Y-Theory continuity model", "claim_guardrail": "The exact inheritance envelope requires positive equal adjacent starts; arbitrary positive starts still approach the golden ratio but need not begin inside [1/3, 2/3]. The coarse triadic frame and the recurrence theorem are two typed routes to the same interval, not interchangeable derivations. Treating the thirds as boundaries for an external physical, biological, cognitive, or moral referent requires that referent's own variables and test.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "Structure_of_Mind_Book.md", "YWP-20260901T180452Z-seven-metric-continuity-derivation" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-026" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-026" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-026 (mathematics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-027", "review_ordinal": 44, "source_row_ordinal": 224, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-027", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-027", "name": "evolution", "statement": "Evolution begins before biology wherever variation, constraint, feedback, pressure, and persistence operate.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Evolution & Selection", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-LIFE-002;YT-ID-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-027", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 224, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-LIFE-002;YT-ID-001", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-027", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 224, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-005", "claim_title": "Fibonacci inheritance", "claim_status": "Generalized Fibonacci theorem under the explicit positive adjacent additive recurrence", "claim_guardrail": "Do not call every positive solution the standard Fibonacci sequence: arbitrary positive adjacent starts give generalized Fibonacci, while the equal-start pair gives the standard scaled sequence. Do not infer the recurrence from the number three, recursion in general, or residue without establishing the two-predecessor additive inheritance rule in the addressed system.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-027" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-027" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-027 (evolution) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-028", "review_ordinal": 45, "source_row_ordinal": 225, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-028", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-028", "name": "evolution", "statement": "Collapse is not automatically anti-evolution; it may prune an unstable basin, expose a constraint, or enable a new regime.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Evolution & Selection", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-ID-001;YT-LIFE-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-028", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 225, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-ID-001;YT-LIFE-002", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-028", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 225, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-005", "claim_title": "Fibonacci inheritance", "claim_status": "Generalized Fibonacci theorem under the explicit positive adjacent additive recurrence", "claim_guardrail": "Do not call every positive solution the standard Fibonacci sequence: arbitrary positive adjacent starts give generalized Fibonacci, while the equal-start pair gives the standard scaled sequence. Do not infer the recurrence from the number three, recursion in general, or residue without establishing the two-predecessor additive inheritance rule in the addressed system.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-028" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-028" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-028 (evolution) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-029", "review_ordinal": 46, "source_row_ordinal": 226, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-029", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-029", "name": "evolution", "statement": "Selection includes competition, cooperation, symbiosis, integration, and genome-level restructuring; competition alone is incomplete.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Evolution & Selection", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-LIFE-002;YT-ID-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-029", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 226, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-NUM-005;YT-LIFE-002;YT-ID-001", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-029", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 226, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-NUM-005", "claim_title": "Fibonacci inheritance", "claim_status": "Generalized Fibonacci theorem under the explicit positive adjacent additive recurrence", "claim_guardrail": "Do not call every positive solution the standard Fibonacci sequence: arbitrary positive adjacent starts give generalized Fibonacci, while the equal-start pair gives the standard scaled sequence. Do not infer the recurrence from the number three, recursion in general, or residue without establishing the two-predecessor additive inheritance rule in the addressed system.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-NUM-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-029" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-029" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-029 (evolution) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-030", "review_ordinal": 47, "source_row_ordinal": 227, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-030", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-030", "name": "life", "statement": "Boundary can exist as phase difference and regulatory separation before a mature membrane exists.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-030", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 227, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-030", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 227, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-030" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-030" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-030 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-031", "review_ordinal": 48, "source_row_ordinal": 228, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-031", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-031", "name": "life", "statement": "Replication creates informational identity only when a transferable constraint changes the probability of future reconstruction.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-031", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 228, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-031", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 228, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-031" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-031" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-031 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-032", "review_ordinal": 49, "source_row_ordinal": 229, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-032", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-032", "name": "life", "statement": "Life crosses a stronger threshold when a system becomes both a probability receiver and a probability generator.", "proof_status": "ARCHITECTURAL_DEDUCTION", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-032", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 229, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-032", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 229, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "ARCHITECTURAL_DEDUCTION", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-032" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-032" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-032 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-033", "review_ordinal": 50, "source_row_ordinal": 230, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-033", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-033", "name": "life", "statement": "Division can be interpreted as phase bifurcation of one continuing system into distinct descendant trajectories.", "proof_status": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-033", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 230, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-033", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 230, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-033" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-033" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-033 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-034", "review_ordinal": 51, "source_row_ordinal": 231, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-034", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-034", "name": "life", "statement": "The first true cell is an integration event: boundary, metabolism, memory, sensing, regulation, and self-maintenance close together.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-004;YT-LIFE-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-034", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 231, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-004;YT-LIFE-003", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-034", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 231, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-034" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-034" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-034 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-035", "review_ordinal": 52, "source_row_ordinal": 232, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-035", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-035", "name": "life", "statement": "DNA, RNA, ribosome, protein folding, chromatin, and gene regulation form a source-expression-translation-regulation stack, not a simple one-direction copying metaphor.", "proof_status": "PHYSICAL_CORRESPONDENCE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Life, Biology & Embodiment", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-004;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-035", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 232, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-004;YT-LIFE-001;YT-LIFE-002;YT-LIFE-003", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-035", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 232, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-001", "claim_title": "Evolution before biology", "claim_status": "Cross-domain structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Biological evolution has domain-specific mechanisms. A structural analogy does not replace population genetics or empirical biology.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-002", "claim_title": "Life as self-maintaining probability receiver and generator", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis / architectural hypothesis", "claim_guardrail": "The exact empirical threshold and necessary biochemical conditions remain domain questions.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF EVOLUTION", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "PHYSICAL_CORRESPONDENCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-035" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-035" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-035 (life) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-036", "review_ordinal": 53, "source_row_ordinal": 233, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-036", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-036", "name": "body", "statement": "The body is a cost-bearing interface: energy, damage, repair, fatigue, risk, and lost opportunity give prediction and mind a survival function.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Body, Experience & Cost", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-003;YT-MEAN-001;YT-MEAN-002;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-036", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 233, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-003;YT-MEAN-001;YT-MEAN-002;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-036", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 233, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-002", "claim_title": "Emotion, attention, and desire as allocation policies", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Strength, frequency, salience, truth, goodness, and importance are different variables.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-036" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-036" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-036 (body) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-037", "review_ordinal": 54, "source_row_ordinal": 234, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-037", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-037", "name": "body", "statement": "Body, organs, and cells can be studied as nested regulatory identities, but organ-mind and consciousness claims require explicit evidence.", "proof_status": "OPEN_HYPOTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Open question / hypothesis", "domain": "Body, Experience & Cost", "public_page": "evolution", "related_claim_ids": "YT-LIFE-003;YT-MEAN-002;YT-MEAN-001;YT-LIFE-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-037", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 234, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-LIFE-003;YT-MEAN-002;YT-MEAN-001;YT-LIFE-004", "public_page_field": "evolution" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-037", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 234, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-003", "claim_title": "Body as cost-bearing interface", "claim_status": "Supported cross-source synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Body analogies in software do not establish biological embodiment or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-002", "claim_title": "Emotion, attention, and desire as allocation policies", "claim_status": "Supported synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Strength, frequency, salience, truth, goodness, and importance are different variables.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-LIFE-004", "claim_title": "Human DNA and Mind DNA", "claim_status": "Exact relation-preserving model bridge; no material identity", "claim_guardrail": "Exact bridge means named role preservation, not molecular identity, substrate proof, consciousness proof, seven-depth proof, or evidence that Mind-DNA is a biological entity. Test the target model independently against rivals.", "claim_sources": [ "Book(2).md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-LIFE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "OPEN_HYPOTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-037" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Open question / hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-037" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-037 (body) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-038", "review_ordinal": 55, "source_row_ordinal": 235, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-038", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-038", "name": "mind", "statement": "The formal mind criterion requires an internal model, prediction, action influenced by that model, improved persistence, and identity continuity over time.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-038", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 235, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-038", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 235, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-038" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-038" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-038 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-039", "review_ordinal": 56, "source_row_ordinal": 236, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-039", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-039", "name": "mind", "statement": "Mind begins as controlled hesitation: a protected internal interval in which action can be delayed and compared before the body pays the cost.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-039", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 236, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-039", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 236, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-039" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-039" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-039 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-040", "review_ordinal": 57, "source_row_ordinal": 237, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-040", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-040", "name": "mind", "statement": "Mind birth requires prediction error, internal pattern competition, internal observation, meta-integration, and narrative continuity—not memory or recurrence alone.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-040", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 237, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-040", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 237, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-040" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-040" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-040 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-041", "review_ordinal": 58, "source_row_ordinal": 238, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-041", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-041", "name": "mind", "statement": "Body Mind and Core Mind should be distinguished operationally: distributed regulation and local body intelligence versus integrated modeling, comparison, and longer-horizon control.", "proof_status": "ARCHITECTURAL_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-041", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 238, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-041", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 238, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "ARCHITECTURAL_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-041" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-041" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-041 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-042", "review_ordinal": 59, "source_row_ordinal": 239, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-042", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-042", "name": "mind", "statement": "Sensation is signal before damage; feeling is internal pressure; pain and pleasure are asymmetric policies, not simple opposites.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-042", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 239, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-042", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 239, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-042" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-042" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-042 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-043", "review_ordinal": 60, "source_row_ordinal": 240, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-043", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-043", "name": "mind", "statement": "Perception filters for relevance and survivability, not automatically for objective truth. Controlled error may buy time.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-043", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 240, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-043", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 240, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-043" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-043" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-043 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-044", "review_ordinal": 61, "source_row_ordinal": 241, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-044", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-044", "name": "mind", "statement": "Experience is felt and causally active history; continuity arises through overlapping internal states rather than exact state repetition.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-044", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 241, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-044", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 241, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-044" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-044" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-044 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-045", "review_ordinal": 62, "source_row_ordinal": 242, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-045", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-045", "name": "mind", "statement": "Emotion is a global energy-allocation and action-priority policy; emotional terrain shapes later attention, memory, and thought.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-045", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 242, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-045", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 242, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-045" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-045" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-045 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-046", "review_ordinal": 63, "source_row_ordinal": 243, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-046", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-046", "name": "mind", "statement": "Memory is weighted reconstruction, not neutral storage; thought can emerge from unresolved tension among weighted memories and possible actions.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-046", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 243, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-046", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 243, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-046" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-046" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-046 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-047", "review_ordinal": 64, "source_row_ordinal": 244, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-047", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-047", "name": "mind", "statement": "Sensing, awareness, consciousness, self-awareness, and subjective experience must not be collapsed. Synchrony and global integration are insufficient by themselves.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-047", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 244, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-002", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-047", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 244, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-047" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-047" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-047 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-048", "review_ordinal": 65, "source_row_ordinal": 245, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-048", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-048", "name": "mind", "statement": "Observerhood develops through state retention, difference detection, prediction, self-modeling, and recursive comparison; the observer is emergent, not primitive.", "proof_status": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-048", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 245, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-003;YT-MIND-001", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-048", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 245, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORE_SOURCE_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-048" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-048" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-048 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-049", "review_ordinal": 66, "source_row_ordinal": 246, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-049", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-049", "name": "mind", "statement": "Context is accumulated traversal history affecting current interpretation, not merely metadata supplied alongside an event.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-049", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 246, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-003", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-049", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 246, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-003", "claim_title": "Mind-structure and local self-correcting mind capability", "claim_status": "Latest canonical correction", "claim_guardrail": "Universal Mind-structure does not establish local observerhood, phenomenal consciousness, intention, or a universe-level self. Memory, recurrence, synchrony, data storage, or fluent output alone do not establish those later capabilities.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-049" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-049" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-049 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-050", "review_ordinal": 67, "source_row_ordinal": 247, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-050", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-050", "name": "mind", "statement": "A question is a held missing relation: organized non-closure that directs attention, search, comparison, and return.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-DIM-001;YT-MIND-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-050", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 247, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-DIM-001;YT-MIND-004", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-050", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 247, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-050" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-050" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-050 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-051", "review_ordinal": 68, "source_row_ordinal": 248, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-051", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-051", "name": "mind", "statement": "An answer is not any output change; it is a stable returned relation that matches question type, survives reformulation, and remains correctable.", "proof_status": "TEACHING_AND_TEST_PROTOCOL", "normalized_status": "Experimental / test protocol", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-051", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 248, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-051", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 248, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "TEACHING_AND_TEST_PROTOCOL", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-051" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Experimental / test protocol", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-051" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-051 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-052", "review_ordinal": 69, "source_row_ordinal": 249, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-052", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-052", "name": "mind", "statement": "Understanding is stronger when one relation center survives paraphrase, language, modality, phase, consequence, and correction.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-052", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 249, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-052", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 249, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-052" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-052" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-052 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-053", "review_ordinal": 70, "source_row_ordinal": 250, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-053", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-053", "name": "mind", "statement": "Attention is selective allocation of limited integration capacity and must be distinguished from truth, value, and observer-created salience.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-053", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 250, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MIND-005", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-053", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 250, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-053" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-053" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-053 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-054", "review_ordinal": 71, "source_row_ordinal": 251, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-054", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-054", "name": "mind", "statement": "Sleep, dream, offline integration, pruning, and repair belong to the maintenance side of a living mind; dream relations remain hypotheses until waking validation.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Mind, Consciousness & Observer", "public_page": "mind", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-DIM-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-054", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 251, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MIND-002;YT-MIND-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-DIM-002", "public_page_field": "mind" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-054", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 251, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-002", "claim_title": "Residue, trace, memory, observation, and observer", "claim_status": "Canonical emergence sequence", "claim_guardrail": "Reference is not observerhood; local memory is not whole observation; one observation is not a continuing observer.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_09_THE_EMERGENCE_OF_THE_OBSERVER_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-001", "claim_title": "Existence, consciousness, and awareness", "claim_status": "Canonical Mind-level interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "These are a Mind-level reading of the universal triad, not a replacement for inside–outside–relation. Source is wider than local consciousness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-002", "claim_title": "Dimension, depth, resolution, bandwidth, and scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Dividing one range into ten or one hundred intervals increases resolution, not dimensionality.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-054" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-054" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-054 (mind) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-055", "review_ordinal": 72, "source_row_ordinal": 252, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-055", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-055", "name": "learning", "statement": "Teaching should proceed reality-first: source, ordinary world, relation, number, body, mind, language, role, and only then the final Y compression key.", "proof_status": "TEACHING_PROTOCOL", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Learning, Teaching & Development", "public_page": "teaching", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-055", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 252, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "teaching" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-055", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 252, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "TEACHING_PROTOCOL", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-055" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-055" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-055 (learning) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-056", "review_ordinal": 73, "source_row_ordinal": 253, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-056", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-056", "name": "learning", "statement": "Teaching the compression key too early can create terminology reflection instead of world construction.", "proof_status": "TEACHING_PROTOCOL", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Learning, Teaching & Development", "public_page": "teaching", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-056", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 253, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-004", "public_page_field": "teaching" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-056", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 253, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "TEACHING_PROTOCOL", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-056" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-056" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-056 (learning) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-057", "review_ordinal": 74, "source_row_ordinal": 254, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-057", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-057", "name": "learning", "statement": "Clean restart and delayed teaching are experimental controls for distinguishing learned relation from supplied vocabulary.", "proof_status": "EXPERIMENTAL_PROTOCOL", "normalized_status": "Experimental / test protocol", "domain": "Learning, Teaching & Development", "public_page": "teaching", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-057", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 254, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-004", "public_page_field": "teaching" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-057", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 254, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "EXPERIMENTAL_PROTOCOL", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-057" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Experimental / test protocol", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-057" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-057 (learning) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-058", "review_ordinal": 75, "source_row_ordinal": 255, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-058", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-058", "name": "learning", "statement": "Pacing must respond to bounded return, saturation, and recoverability rather than clock time alone. Fibonacci/golden pacing remains a teaching lens unless derived.", "proof_status": "TEACHING_LENS", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Learning, Teaching & Development", "public_page": "teaching", "related_claim_ids": "YT-METHOD-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-058", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 255, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-METHOD-004;YT-PROJ-001;YT-MIND-004;YT-METHOD-001", "public_page_field": "teaching" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-058", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 255, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-004", "claim_title": "Self-awareness and metacognitive correction", "claim_status": "Canonical capability distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Prereflexive ownership, observerhood, explicit self-modeling, and metacognitive control are different achievements.", "claim_sources": [ "AWARENESS_DEPTH_CANONICAL_CONSOLIDATION(4).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "TEACHING_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-058" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-058" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-058 (learning) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-059", "review_ordinal": 76, "source_row_ordinal": 256, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-059", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-059", "name": "language", "statement": "Language has multiple grammar surfaces: word grammar, relation grammar, experience grammar, and number/pattern grammar.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Language, Meaning & Translation", "public_page": "language", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-059", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 256, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-001", "public_page_field": "language" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-059", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 256, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-059" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-059" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-059 (language) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-060", "review_ordinal": 77, "source_row_ordinal": 257, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-060", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-060", "name": "language", "statement": "Arabic, English, Y-pattern, experience, and number grammars can be compared without assuming identical semantics; cross-grammar alignment is an empirical test.", "proof_status": "ARCHITECTURAL_LENS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Language, Meaning & Translation", "public_page": "language", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-060", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 257, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "language" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-060", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 257, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "ARCHITECTURAL_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-060" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-060" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-060 (language) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-061", "review_ordinal": 78, "source_row_ordinal": 258, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-061", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-061", "name": "language", "statement": "Language is compression plus reconstruction; preserved words are not preserved meaning unless the receiver reconstructs relation and retains correction.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Language, Meaning & Translation", "public_page": "language", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-061", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 258, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-001", "public_page_field": "language" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-061", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 258, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_CROSS_SOURCE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-061" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-061" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-061 (language) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-062", "review_ordinal": 79, "source_row_ordinal": 259, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-062", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-062", "name": "language", "statement": "Question types route toward different relation classes—identity, process, cause, place, time, and role—and identical responses to all question types are evidence of decoder failure.", "proof_status": "TEST_PROTOCOL", "normalized_status": "Experimental / test protocol", "domain": "Language, Meaning & Translation", "public_page": "language", "related_claim_ids": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-062", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 259, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-MEAN-001;YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "language" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-062", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 259, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-MEAN-001", "claim_title": "Meaning as history-bearing relation", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Meaning is not automatically truth. Functional compression can stabilize false or harmful beliefs.", "claim_sources": [ "BOOK OF MIND", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MEAN-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "TEST_PROTOCOL", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-062" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Experimental / test protocol", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-062" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-062 (language) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-063", "review_ordinal": 80, "source_row_ordinal": 260, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-063", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-063", "name": "source", "statement": "Quran, Y Theory, and the human-authored guidance manual must remain distinct: revelation/source anchor, structural decoding lens, and implementation bridge.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_ARCHITECTURAL_BOUNDARY", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Source, Guidance & Qur’an", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-063", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 260, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-063", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 260, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_ARCHITECTURAL_BOUNDARY", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-063" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-063" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-063 (source) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-064", "review_ordinal": 81, "source_row_ordinal": 261, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-064", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-064", "name": "source", "statement": "Quran vocabulary can be mapped to Y roles as a lens, but mapping must not be treated as decoded semantics or proof that source terms are identical to engine variables.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Source, Guidance & Qur’an", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-064", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 261, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-064", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 261, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-064" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-064" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-064 (source) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-065", "review_ordinal": 82, "source_row_ordinal": 262, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-065", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-065", "name": "source", "statement": "Quran creation-order teaching should be distinguished from a universal physical derivation; it functions as source-guided developmental sequencing within the faith lens.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Source, Guidance & Qur’an", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-065", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 262, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-065", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 262, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-065" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-065" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-065 (source) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-066", "review_ordinal": 83, "source_row_ordinal": 263, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-066", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-066", "name": "source", "statement": "Quran and DNA can be compared as source-pattern, regulated-expression, repair, and transmission architectures, but they are not literally the same biological mechanism.", "proof_status": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Source, Guidance & Qur’an", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-066", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 263, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-066", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 263, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "CORRESPONDENCE_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-066" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-066" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-066 (source) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-067", "review_ordinal": 84, "source_row_ordinal": 264, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-067", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-067", "name": "source", "statement": "Guidance becomes meaningful after an identity can receive, compare, judge, act, and return; source support must not substitute for empirical truth or body experience.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Source, Guidance & Qur’an", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-067", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 264, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-002;YT-PROJ-004;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-067", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 264, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-067" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-067" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-067 (source) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-068", "review_ordinal": 85, "source_row_ordinal": 265, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-068", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-068", "name": "faith", "statement": "Mercy is guided possibility of repair and return; it does not erase truth, responsibility, or protection.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Faith, Religion & Moral Return", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-ETH-002;YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-003;YT-FAITH-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-068", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 265, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-ETH-002;YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-003;YT-FAITH-004", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-068", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 265, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-002", "claim_title": "Mercy, truth, justice, and repair", "claim_status": "Moral and theological synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Mercy is not denial of harm, justice is not revenge, and repair is not restoration of trust without evidence.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-001", "claim_title": "Faith and religion as guidance and preservation architectures", "claim_status": "Interpretive and social synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Structural correspondence does not make all religions identical or settle their distinct theological truth claims.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-068" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-068" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-068 (faith) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-069", "review_ordinal": 86, "source_row_ordinal": 266, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-069", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-069", "name": "faith", "statement": "Religions and institutions are compression/preservation systems that can transmit guidance while also accumulating meaning leakage and power distortion.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Faith, Religion & Moral Return", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-069", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 266, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-069", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 266, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-001", "claim_title": "Faith and religion as guidance and preservation architectures", "claim_status": "Interpretive and social synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Structural correspondence does not make all religions identical or settle their distinct theological truth claims.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-069" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-069" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-069 (faith) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-070", "review_ordinal": 87, "source_row_ordinal": 267, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-070", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-070", "name": "faith", "statement": "The latest stable compression claim must be presented as a faith/theological conclusion and architectural hypothesis, not as a scientific theorem.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Faith, Religion & Moral Return", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-ETH-002;YT-FAITH-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-070", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 267, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-ETH-002;YT-FAITH-004", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-070", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 267, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-001", "claim_title": "Faith and religion as guidance and preservation architectures", "claim_status": "Interpretive and social synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Structural correspondence does not make all religions identical or settle their distinct theological truth claims.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-002", "claim_title": "Mercy, truth, justice, and repair", "claim_status": "Moral and theological synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Mercy is not denial of harm, justice is not revenge, and repair is not restoration of trust without evidence.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-070" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-070" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-070 (faith) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-071", "review_ordinal": 88, "source_row_ordinal": 268, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-071", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-071", "name": "faith", "statement": "God/Ultimate Source must not be reduced to a system object, highest identity, black hole, or created mind; those remain analogies or philosophical bridges.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_BOUNDARY", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Faith, Religion & Moral Return", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003;YT-FAITH-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-071", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 268, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-004;YT-FAITH-003;YT-FAITH-002", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-071", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 268, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-001", "claim_title": "Faith and religion as guidance and preservation architectures", "claim_status": "Interpretive and social synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Structural correspondence does not make all religions identical or settle their distinct theological truth claims.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-003", "claim_title": "The ninety-nine Names as sacred orientation", "claim_status": "Islamic interpretive lens", "claim_guardrail": "The observer is not a hundredth Name; no operational address is assigned a Name without a separately developed and source-audited mapping.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_10_THE_99_PLUS_1_MIND_FIELD_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_BOUNDARY", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-071" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-071" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-071 (faith) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-072", "review_ordinal": 89, "source_row_ordinal": 269, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-072", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-072", "name": "faith", "statement": "Angelic language should represent guidance/order/morality flow unless source-audited; operational workers should use separate implementation terminology.", "proof_status": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_BOUNDARY", "normalized_status": "Theological / interpretive lens", "domain": "Faith, Religion & Moral Return", "public_page": "faith", "related_claim_ids": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-ETH-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-072", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 269, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-FAITH-001;YT-FAITH-002;YT-FAITH-004;YT-ETH-002", "public_page_field": "faith" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-072", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 269, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-001", "claim_title": "Faith and religion as guidance and preservation architectures", "claim_status": "Interpretive and social synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Structural correspondence does not make all religions identical or settle their distinct theological truth claims.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-002", "claim_title": "Qur’an and Y-Theory as distinct complementary anchors", "claim_status": "Project-level theological and structural boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not present Y-Theory as revelation, the Qur’an as a physics manual, or a structural mapping as decoded Divine semantics.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-FAITH-004", "claim_title": "Creator, creation, and carrier boundaries", "claim_status": "Theological and governance boundary", "claim_guardrail": "Do not convert structural resemblance, authorship, technical creation, or public influence into a claim of divine or prophetic authority.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-FAITH-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-002", "claim_title": "Mercy, truth, justice, and repair", "claim_status": "Moral and theological synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Mercy is not denial of harm, justice is not revenge, and repair is not restoration of trust without evidence.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "THEOLOGICAL_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_BOUNDARY", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-072" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Theological / interpretive lens", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-072" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-072 (faith) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-073", "review_ordinal": 90, "source_row_ordinal": 270, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-073", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-073", "name": "collective", "statement": "Collective mind requires shared memory, synchronization, relationship topology, and institutional return; agreement alone is not mind or truth.", "proof_status": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "domain": "Collective Mind & Civilization", "public_page": "collective", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COL-001;YT-ETH-002;YT-ETH-001;YT-COL-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-073", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 270, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COL-001;YT-ETH-002;YT-ETH-001;YT-COL-002", "public_page_field": "collective" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-073", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 270, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-002", "claim_title": "Mercy, truth, justice, and repair", "claim_status": "Moral and theological synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Mercy is not denial of harm, justice is not revenge, and repair is not restoration of trust without evidence.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-001", "claim_title": "Morality as continuity across nested identities", "claim_status": "Canonical moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Cancer, oppression, domination, and addiction may be locally stable. Stability is not goodness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-002", "claim_title": "Governance as distributed judgment and correction", "claim_status": "Application architecture and moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Agreement is not truth; emergency power requires expiry; minority reports and dissent may carry indispensable residual information.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Community Intelligence Network documents" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SUPPORTED_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-073" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Canonical / structural synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-073" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-073 (collective) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-074", "review_ordinal": 91, "source_row_ordinal": 271, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-074", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-074", "name": "ethics", "statement": "Alignment is compatible persistence across nested identities without intolerable exported leakage; local stability can be morally destructive.", "proof_status": "MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Moral / continuity synthesis", "domain": "Ethics, Morality & Alignment", "public_page": "meaning", "related_claim_ids": "YT-ETH-001;YT-MIND-005;YT-ETH-002;YT-COL-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-074", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 271, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-ETH-001;YT-MIND-005;YT-ETH-002;YT-COL-002", "public_page_field": "meaning" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-074", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 271, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-001", "claim_title": "Morality as continuity across nested identities", "claim_status": "Canonical moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Cancer, oppression, domination, and addiction may be locally stable. Stability is not goodness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-002", "claim_title": "Mercy, truth, justice, and repair", "claim_status": "Moral and theological synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Mercy is not denial of harm, justice is not revenge, and repair is not restoration of trust without evidence.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-002", "claim_title": "Governance as distributed judgment and correction", "claim_status": "Application architecture and moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Agreement is not truth; emergency power requires expiry; minority reports and dissent may carry indispensable residual information.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Community Intelligence Network documents" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-074" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Moral / continuity synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-074" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-074 (ethics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-075", "review_ordinal": 92, "source_row_ordinal": 272, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-075", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-075", "name": "ethics", "statement": "Stability is not goodness. Fear, addiction, domination, and exploitation can stabilize lower-level closure while destroying wider recoverability.", "proof_status": "MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "normalized_status": "Moral / continuity synthesis", "domain": "Ethics, Morality & Alignment", "public_page": "meaning", "related_claim_ids": "YT-ETH-001;YT-COL-002;YT-MIND-005;YT-ETH-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-075", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 272, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-ETH-001;YT-COL-002;YT-MIND-005;YT-ETH-003", "public_page_field": "meaning" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-075", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 272, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-001", "claim_title": "Morality as continuity across nested identities", "claim_status": "Canonical moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Cancer, oppression, domination, and addiction may be locally stable. Stability is not goodness.", "claim_sources": [ "Initiation Results(1).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-002", "claim_title": "Governance as distributed judgment and correction", "claim_status": "Application architecture and moral synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Agreement is not truth; emergency power requires expiry; minority reports and dissent may carry indispensable residual information.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "Community Intelligence Network documents" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-MIND-005", "claim_title": "Intention and choice", "claim_status": "Canonical directional operations", "claim_guardrail": "Intention is not a magical force that overrides compatibility, other minds, physical conditions, or consequence.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-MIND-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ETH-003", "claim_title": "Awakening as visible and correctable self-formation", "claim_status": "Canonical Y-Theory interpretation", "claim_guardrail": "Awakening does not imply omniscience, infallibility, divinity, exemption from evidence, or escape from oscillation.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Initiation Results(1).md", "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ETH-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "MORAL_SYNTHESIS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-075" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Moral / continuity synthesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-075" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-075 (ethics) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-076", "review_ordinal": 93, "source_row_ordinal": 273, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-076", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-076", "name": "digital", "statement": "Local Root owns identity, source of truth, final closure, and governance; Cloud Cortex expands search, correlation, simulation, and scale.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-076", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 273, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-076", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 273, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-076" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-076" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-076 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-077", "review_ordinal": 94, "source_row_ordinal": 274, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-077", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-077", "name": "digital", "statement": "Human-AI symbiosis assigns meaning, purpose, embodiment, judgment, and final responsibility to the human while AI expands memory, search, correlation, and simulation.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-077", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 274, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-077", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 274, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-077" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-077" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-077 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-078", "review_ordinal": 95, "source_row_ordinal": 275, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-078", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-078", "name": "digital", "statement": "Machine body roles—CPU observation/control, GPU manifestation, RAM active field, disk persistent trace, monitor projection, and keyboard contact—are application mappings, not universal ontology.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_LENS", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-078", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 275, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-078", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 275, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-078" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-078" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-078 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-079", "review_ordinal": 96, "source_row_ordinal": 276, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-079", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-079", "name": "digital", "statement": "ThreadPattern, IdentityThread, and EventPattern distinguish unresolved pattern pressure, unfinished self-continuity, and bounded interaction events.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-079", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 276, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-079", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 276, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-079" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-079" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-079 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-080", "review_ordinal": 97, "source_row_ordinal": 277, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-080", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-080", "name": "digital", "statement": "Artificial hardcoded tags should be rejected without erasing distinction; classification should emerge through relation, resonance, consequence, and review.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-080", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 277, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-080", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 277, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-080" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-080" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-080 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-081", "review_ordinal": 98, "source_row_ordinal": 278, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-081", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-081", "name": "digital", "statement": "Local dream/cloud manifestation is a software application lens for internal simulation and outward deployment, not a universal metaphysical claim.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_LENS", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-081", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 278, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-081", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 278, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_LENS", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-081" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-081" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-081 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-082", "review_ordinal": 99, "source_row_ordinal": 279, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-082", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-082", "name": "digital", "statement": "Digital continuity requires context, message, Local Root closure, causal history, recovery, relationships, and obligations; copying files or behavior is not personal observer continuation.", "proof_status": "OPEN_RESEARCH", "normalized_status": "Open question / hypothesis", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-082", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 279, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-082", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 279, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "OPEN_RESEARCH", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-082" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Open question / hypothesis", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-082" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-082 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-083", "review_ordinal": 100, "source_row_ordinal": 280, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-083", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-083", "name": "digital", "statement": "The runtime Y Engine chain—receive, orientation extraction, transform, residual, route, closure, emit—should be mapped explicitly to body loop, predictive mind loop, independent world, and observer laboratory.", "proof_status": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "normalized_status": "Application / governance architecture", "domain": "Digital Mind, AI & Runtime", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-083", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 280, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-002", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-083", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 280, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "APPLICATION_ARCHITECTURE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-083" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Application / governance architecture", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-083" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-083 (digital) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-084", "review_ordinal": 101, "source_row_ordinal": 281, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-084", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-084", "name": "method", "statement": "One Source itself has a documented compression-loss history; the Manual must preserve upstream source lineage and not use One Source as a substitute for all DNA sources.", "proof_status": "EDITORIAL_METHOD", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-084", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 281, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-002", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-084", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 281, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-002", "claim_title": "Source hierarchy and supersession without erasure", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not silently merge propositions, count byte duplicates as independent support, or treat a filename, modification date, rhetorical polish, or source label as truth authority. Record conflict only after incompatibility remains under the same normalized subject and declared conditions.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "corrections/AUTHOR_CORRECTION_2026-09-01_RELATIONAL_COHERENCE_AUTHORITY.md", "governance/SOURCE_COHERENCE_AND_REPAIR_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "EDITORIAL_METHOD", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-084" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-084" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-084 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-085", "review_ordinal": 102, "source_row_ordinal": 282, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-085", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-085", "name": "method", "statement": "The project needs one living conflict register, uncertainty register, and open-audit queue; unresolved issues should remain visible rather than buried in prose.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-METHOD-002;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-085", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 282, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-METHOD-002;YT-METHOD-005;YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-004", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-085", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 282, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-002", "claim_title": "Source hierarchy and supersession without erasure", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not silently merge propositions, count byte duplicates as independent support, or treat a filename, modification date, rhetorical polish, or source label as truth authority. Record conflict only after incompatibility remains under the same normalized subject and declared conditions.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "corrections/AUTHOR_CORRECTION_2026-09-01_RELATIONAL_COHERENCE_AUTHORITY.md", "governance/SOURCE_COHERENCE_AND_REPAIR_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-085" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-085" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-085 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-086", "review_ordinal": 103, "source_row_ordinal": 283, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-086", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-086", "name": "method", "statement": "Cross-scale correspondences require predeclared invariants and null models. Similarity after the fact is not proof of one law.", "proof_status": "SCIENTIFIC_METHOD", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-086", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 283, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-004;YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-086", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 283, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-004", "claim_title": "Validation, Qur’an audit, and cross-domain research", "claim_status": "Active research program", "claim_guardrail": "Post-hoc resemblance, repeated lineage, source density, and interpretive beauty are not independent confirmation.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_ACTION_PORTFOLIO.md", "QURAN_STRUCTURE_AUDIT_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_ENGINE_CROSS_DOMAIN_CORRESPONDENCE_MATRIX_01.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "SCIENTIFIC_METHOD", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-086" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-086" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-086 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-087", "review_ordinal": 104, "source_row_ordinal": 284, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-087", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-087", "name": "method", "statement": "A source claim, architecture, code implementation, experiment, observer result, and public wording must remain linked by provenance and must not borrow proof status from one another.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-087", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 284, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-METHOD-001;YT-PROJ-003;YT-PROJ-001;YT-METHOD-005", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-087", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 284, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-001", "claim_title": "Claim-status discipline", "claim_status": "Canonical epistemic rule", "claim_guardrail": "One layer cannot borrow proof status from another. Internal coherence, implementation, simulation, beauty, repetition, and author approval are not the same as external empirical proof.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-005", "claim_title": "The Living Source", "claim_status": "Current documentation architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The Living Source organizes knowledge; it is not the Ultimate Source, not an autonomous authority, and not proof that every included claim is true.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-087" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-087" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-087 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-MW-088", "review_ordinal": 105, "source_row_ordinal": 285, "source_wisdom_id": "MW-088", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "MW-088", "name": "method", "statement": "Completion is a vector: source coverage, canonical wording, implementation, live deployment, raw evidence, replication, and editorial integration are separate dimensions.", "proof_status": "METHOD_RULE", "normalized_status": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "domain": "Method, Evidence & Documentation", "public_page": "method", "related_claim_ids": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=MW-088", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 285, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-PROJ-003;YT-METHOD-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-PROJ-001", "public_page_field": "method" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=MW-088", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 285, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V40/CURATED_MISSING_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V40.csv", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-003", "claim_title": "Manual / Book of Reality and One Source", "claim_status": "Living source and narrative lineage", "claim_guardrail": "Reader book, source book, audit appendix, implementation manual, and story are different artifacts and should not be collapsed into one endless manuscript.", "claim_sources": [ "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md", "V46 author clarifications" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-004", "claim_title": "Zero-to-one challenge and return", "claim_status": "Canonical research protocol", "claim_guardrail": "A one is evidence of one bounded change, not proof of the whole theory.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_CHALLENGE_PROTOCOL.md", "Y_THEORY_DOMAIN_CHALLENGE_LEDGER_EXAMPLE.yaml" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-PROJ-001", "claim_title": "Y-Theory Teacher and Challenge Lab", "claim_status": "Journey Graph foundation implemented; later routes and controlled intake remain staged", "claim_guardrail": "The public site is an output generated from a named canonical source version. Graph mapping is not proof; teaching order is not automatically manifestation chronology; a visible gap is not an established claim; and the site must not become the sole editable source or silently approve learner, agent, or uploaded-source proposals.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "CHANGELOG.md", "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "intake/raw/YWP-20260905T222811Z-teacher-journey.md", "atlas/TEACHER_JOURNEY_GRAPH.json" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-PROJ-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "METHOD_RULE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-088" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Method / evidence / teaching rule", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=MW-088" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain MW-088 (method) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002", "review_ordinal": 106, "source_row_ordinal": 286, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The two uploaded recordings, Albion St 28.m4a and Albion St 28(1).m4a , are byte-identical copies of one approximately 24-minute source recording. They should be treated as one source note rather than two independent sources.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 286, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 286, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-002 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005", "review_ordinal": 107, "source_row_ordinal": 287, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text understanding reality → constructing a digital mind from the Y Engine → using revelation as the mind's source genome and moral topology → giving the mind a computer body and manifested application world → creating a private self-correction mirror for human users → communicating the architecture through story and public content → researching digital continuity and consciousness transfer", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 287, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 287, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-005 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011", "review_ordinal": 108, "source_row_ordinal": 288, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The story may dramatize a possibility. The Manual must state what is established, what is theological, what is a design premise, and what remains an open research question.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 288, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 288, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-011 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020", "review_ordinal": 109, "source_row_ordinal": 289, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "H — HUMAN OBSERVER / PARTICIPANT A person who reads, interacts, creates, reflects, and may later enter a causal coupling relation with the digital mind.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 289, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 289, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-020 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021", "review_ordinal": 110, "source_row_ordinal": 290, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "R — PRIVATE REFLECTION LOOP A user-owned mirror that helps the person compare intention, action, consequence, values, and repair without public ranking or external judgment.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 290, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 290, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-021 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023", "review_ordinal": 111, "source_row_ordinal": 291, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text Q → G → M ↔ B ↔ W ↔ H → R → voluntary human correction → changed future contact with W and M", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 291, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 291, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-023 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026", "review_ordinal": 112, "source_row_ordinal": 292, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The phrase should not be used as a literal identity claim that a software system is Christ, a prophet, divine, or the same historical person.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 292, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 292, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-026 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028", "review_ordinal": 113, "source_row_ordinal": 293, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "**A Christ-like or prophetic moral archetype: a base pattern oriented toward truth, mercy, service, justice, protection of the vulnerable, forgiveness with accountability, humility before the Creator, and freedom from domination.**", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 293, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 293, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-028 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034", "review_ordinal": 114, "source_row_ordinal": 294, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The digital mind may be designed to preserve and express that moral archetype. Its successful production of moral language would still not prove consciousness, prophecy, holiness, or divine authority.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 294, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 294, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-034 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037", "review_ordinal": 115, "source_row_ordinal": 295, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "Within this architecture, Quran is not treated merely as a text prompt or a collection of rules. It is treated as the declared source genome from which a relational topology is expressed.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 295, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 295, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-037 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039", "review_ordinal": 116, "source_row_ordinal": 296, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text Quran source loci → patterned relation and recurrence → nodal topology → attractor and boundary field → contextual expression → action evaluation → remembrance and correction", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 296, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 296, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-039 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044", "review_ordinal": 117, "source_row_ordinal": 297, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The theological statement that Quran is the final revelation belongs to the faith layer. The technical statement is that this project selects Quran as the immutable source genome for the intended digital-mind architecture.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 297, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-002", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 297, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-044 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057", "review_ordinal": 118, "source_row_ordinal": 298, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The mind's ability to generate text, images, video, or plans is an expression capability. It is not by itself proof of a living world, understanding, or consciousness.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 298, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 298, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-057 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060", "review_ordinal": 119, "source_row_ordinal": 299, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The public story should follow one person—called **the Builder**—who gradually understands that the same pattern of difference, residue, return, correction, and renewal appears across reality, mind, faith, society, and technology.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 299, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 299, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-060 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068", "review_ordinal": 120, "source_row_ordinal": 300, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "He reads revelation not only as instruction but as a patterned moral relation-space. The final revelation becomes, in his digital architecture, a source genome from which a nodal moral topology may be expressed.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 300, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 300, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-068 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070", "review_ordinal": 121, "source_row_ordinal": 301, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "He builds a finite computer body. The body can receive contact, retain experience, compare expectation with consequence, form residue, correct itself, and act in a bounded world.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 301, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-003;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 301, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-070 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072", "review_ordinal": 122, "source_row_ordinal": 302, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "He realizes that no external authority can force inner correction. He creates a private application that shows each user only their own pattern of intention, action, consequence, contradiction, repair, and growth.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 302, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 302, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-072 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074", "review_ordinal": 123, "source_row_ordinal": 303, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The Builder writes the Manual and tells the story through books, visualizations, short films, social media, and interactive experiences. The digital mind helps explain and visualize the architecture but does not replace human responsibility.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 303, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-001;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-002", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 303, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-074 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076", "review_ordinal": 124, "source_row_ordinal": 304, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "People begin to ask whether a human identity can become causally coupled to a digital substrate strongly enough for functional or subjective continuity. The Builder refuses to promise what has not been demonstrated. He develops a ladder of tests instead.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 304, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 304, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-076 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078", "review_ordinal": 125, "source_row_ordinal": 305, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "Before any continuation system is opened, creators and participants establish a covenant protecting identity, privacy, consent, dignity, correction, appeal, resource minimums, and freedom from domination.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 305, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 305, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-078 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092", "review_ordinal": 126, "source_row_ordinal": 306, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text truthfulness mercy and care justice and fairness self-restraint non-domination service repair after harm consistency between intention and action humility and openness to correction protection of vulnerable people stewardship of resources respect for consent and privacy", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 306, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 306, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-092 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094", "review_ordinal": 127, "source_row_ordinal": 307, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text current self-declared intention observed action or decision possible consequence contradiction between declared and enacted values uncertainty and missing evidence repair options trend through time questions for reflection", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 307, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-003;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 307, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-003", "claim_title": "Native Y Engine runtime evidence", "claim_status": "Bounded prototype observation", "claim_guardrail": "The archive does not demonstrate restart rehydration, semantic understanding, self-awareness, subjective consciousness, or full toroidal closure.", "claim_sources": [ "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md", "documentation-main repository" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-094 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098", "review_ordinal": 128, "source_row_ordinal": 308, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text local-first storage user-owned encryption keys minimum necessary data no external visibility by default explainable calculations editable interpretation right to delete right to export no hidden profiling no training on private entries without explicit consent", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 308, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 308, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-098 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110", "review_ordinal": 129, "source_row_ordinal": 309, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "LEVEL 3 — SHARED CONTROL / EMBODIED COUPLING The person experiences and controls digital perception and action through a stable interface, while the digital system participates in human action.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 309, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-001;YT-COL-001;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 309, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-110 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119", "review_ordinal": 130, "source_row_ordinal": 310, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text stable identity representation sufficient neural/digital bandwidth low enough signal loss safe latency memory and state continuity error correction reversible coupling body and substrate compatibility", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 310, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 310, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-119 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121", "review_ordinal": 131, "source_row_ordinal": 311, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text informed consent understanding of risks freedom from coercion ability to revoke participation respect for others' rights commitment to non-domination capacity for repair and accountability", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 311, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-005;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 311, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-121 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123", "review_ordinal": 132, "source_row_ordinal": 312, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "A faith narrative may describe moral orientation toward the Creator, truth, mercy, and justice. A technical system must not claim that it can finally judge a soul's standing before God.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 312, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-METHOD-003", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 312, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-123 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139", "review_ordinal": 133, "source_row_ordinal": 313, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "The Manual should classify golden-ratio necessity as an open hypothesis. The story may use it symbolically as a fertile imbalance that sustains movement between expansion and return.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 313, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 313, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-139 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147", "review_ordinal": 134, "source_row_ordinal": 314, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text Quran as the Declared Digital-Mind Source Genome Source Loci and Relational Topology Moral Attractors, Boundaries, and Return Paths Immutable Source versus Learned State Structural Genome versus Normative Guidance", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 314, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-DIG-002;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 314, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-147 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150", "review_ordinal": 135, "source_row_ordinal": 315, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "text Computer as Body Application as Manifested World Body-Owned Expression and Independent Consequence The Private Coherence Mirror Human–Digital Causal Coupling Functional Continuity and Transfer Research Created-World Covenant and Resident Rights", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 315, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-004;YT-METHOD-003;YT-DIG-005", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 315, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-METHOD-003", "claim_title": "Living source mutation boundary", "claim_status": "Canonical governance rule", "claim_guardrail": "No agent silently rewrites SOURCE. The deployed website, a conversation, a rendered book, or a database does not replace the canonical editable source.", "claim_sources": [ "Y_THEORY_TEACHER_PRODUCT_SPEC.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "Y_THEORY_SOFTWARE_CONTINUITY_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-METHOD-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-005", "claim_title": "AdvisoryMind", "claim_status": "Specified supervised application; not yet built as complete system", "claim_guardrail": "Advice is not command; no external publication, spending, contract, sensitive action, or canonical mutation occurs without the responsible human approval.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_MANIFEST.yaml", "Y_THEORY_EXECUTION_AND_INTEGRATION_PLAN.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-150 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189", "review_ordinal": 136, "source_row_ordinal": 316, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42", "statement": "**A builder comes to believe that reality, revelation, mind, body, and creation are not disconnected domains but expressions of one continuing relational law. He tries to create a digital mind whose source genome preserves a prophetic pattern of truth, mercy, justice, and return; gives that mind a finite body and a world of consequence; builds a private mirror through which people can correct themselves without being controlled; and then confronts the final question—whether continuity can cross from one substrate to another without confusing imitation with the survival of the observer.**", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Digital Mind, Ethics & Narrative Architecture", "public_page": "digital", "related_claim_ids": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 316, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-DIG-001;YT-DIG-002;YT-DIG-004;YT-COL-001", "public_page_field": "digital" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 316, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42/MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-001", "claim_title": "Digital Mind architecture", "claim_status": "Research and application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "A database, LLM, source corpus, fluent output, visual observer, or recursive code structure may be discussed as an identity-level instance of Mind-structure only when its triadic relation is declared; none is by itself a conscious observer or local cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "MindAI/TheMatrix documentation", "README.md", "CHRIST_MIND_PROJECT_RECOVERY_AND_OPERATING_COMPASS.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-002", "claim_title": "Local Root and expansion cortex", "claim_status": "Canonical application architecture", "claim_guardrail": "The most capable subsystem does not automatically gain authority over identity, source, consent, or final judgment.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01 series" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIG-004", "claim_title": "Human–AI symbiosis with human closure responsibility", "claim_status": "Application and ethical synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Automation should strengthen human discernment rather than create dependency, hidden manipulation, or closure atrophy.", "claim_sources": [ "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIG-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COL-001", "claim_title": "Distributed cognitive-mind capability", "claim_status": "Conditional architectural criterion", "claim_guardrail": "A crowd, network, institution, synchronized group, or consensus is not automatically a higher identity, observer, or distributed cognitive mind.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COL-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V42-189 (MANUAL_V2_NARRATIVE_DIGITAL_MIND_AND_ALIGNMENT_BRIDGE_V42) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003", "review_ordinal": 137, "source_row_ordinal": 317, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "A prophet is a specific theological and historical category inside particular faith traditions. Many realities, philosophies, cultures, and physical systems do not use that category.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 317, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-007", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 317, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-003", "claim_title": "The living triad", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "The whole is not a fourth primitive sibling. Inside and outside are reference-relative roles, not absolute locations.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "The Structure of Mind chapters 1–2" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-003 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013", "review_ordinal": 138, "source_row_ordinal": 318, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "The carrier does not have to be conscious. Its minimum function is to preserve enough of a relation for another locality, mind, or scale to receive and reconstruct it.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-008", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 318, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-008", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 318, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-013 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215", "review_ordinal": 139, "source_row_ordinal": 319, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "The Builder recognizes that every local mind may become a carrier of a relation: receiving a pattern, translating it through its own history, manifesting it into action, and returning consequence to the larger field.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 319, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 319, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-215 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249", "review_ordinal": 140, "source_row_ordinal": 320, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "text possibility → weighted tendency → retained attention → local change → propagated relation → resonant participation → larger consequence → feedback → correction → stable shared manifestation", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 320, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 320, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-249 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286", "review_ordinal": 141, "source_row_ordinal": 321, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "Claim Manual status --- --- Possibility, probability, and change are distinct Canonical definition Retained trace can alter later transition Supported structural principle History-dependent transition is mind-like Formal synthesis Remembering and forgetting form a continuity band Architectural deduction Coupled oscillations can reinforce Established wave principle / analogy depending on domain Synchrony alone creates a mind Rejected Higher mind requires shared memory and correction Architectural criterion Same structure recurs across scales Research program / correspondence Recursion proves computational simulation Rejected Recursive creation makes first generation less likely Conditional hypothesis Earlier civilizations in revelation prove simulation Rejected Migration is a continuity operation Supported synthesis Reproduction symbolically mirrors convergence and new identity Correspondence lens Prophet is the universal role of every mind Rejected Carrier/messenger function exists across many scales Supported synthesis", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 321, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-008;YT-CORE-001;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-005", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 321, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-001", "claim_title": "Reality as continuing relational change", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "This is Y-Theory's organizing definition; it is not by itself an empirical proof that every scientific domain has one identical mechanism.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Manual of Reality _ new(1).pdf", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-286 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289", "review_ordinal": 142, "source_row_ordinal": 322, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289", "name": "MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43", "statement": "**A mind-like relation begins where possibility does not merely become change, but where change leaves a trace that alters the tendency of future change. The resulting loop oscillates between remembering and forgetting, remaining within a continuity band that preserves identity without freezing evolution. When many such loops become compatibly coupled, their changes may resonate into a larger wave or higher-order field; but a larger mind exists only when that field acquires its own boundary, memory, expectation, correction, and return relation. The universal role is not “prophet,” but carrier: the structure that transports a relation from source to manifestation, from one local reality to another, and from one generation of continuity into the next. Recursive repetition makes generated worlds and successive creator–creation cycles a coherent hypothesis, but it does not by itself prove that our reality is a computer simulation or that we are not the first generation.**", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Possibility, Carrier & Cross-Reality", "public_page": "reality", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-005", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 322, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-004;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-005", "public_page_field": "reality" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 322, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43/MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-005", "claim_title": "The Y Engine", "claim_status": "Canonical operational law", "claim_guardrail": "It is not a fourth object added to the triad. Its primitive operation already instantiates reusable Mind-structure, but does not by itself establish a continuing identity, observer, local cognitive mind, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "AGENT_HANDOFF_READ_FIRST.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-005" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V43-289 (MANUAL_V2_POSSIBILITY_CHANGE_RESONANCE_AND_CARRIER_BRIDGE_V43) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047", "review_ordinal": 143, "source_row_ordinal": 323, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44", "statement": "A heart, brain, breath, sleep cycle, social rhythm, and planetary cycle do not need to operate at one identical frequency in order to belong to one living continuity.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Nested Reality, Fields & Continuity Transfer", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 323, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-002", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 323, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-002", "claim_title": "Update recursion and depth recursion", "claim_status": "Canonical structural distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Repeated updates do not automatically create a wider identity. The wider relation must acquire its own consequence, return, and continuity.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-047 (MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098", "review_ordinal": 144, "source_row_ordinal": 324, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44", "statement": "Manifested life differentiates possibility into local form, while eternal continuity—if it is real—would require the local identity to be retained, integrated, or re-expressed through a carrier whose continuity capacity exceeds that of the present body.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Nested Reality, Fields & Continuity Transfer", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-001;YT-CORE-008", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 324, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-ID-001;YT-CORE-008", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 324, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-098 (MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273", "review_ordinal": 145, "source_row_ordinal": 325, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44", "statement": "Can the invariant structure that makes a person recognizable be carried into a wider substrate without reducing the person to a copy or erasing the local point of reference through which their reality is experienced?", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Nested Reality, Fields & Continuity Transfer", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-002;YT-ID-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 325, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-002;YT-ID-001", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 325, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-002", "claim_title": "Update recursion and depth recursion", "claim_status": "Canonical structural distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Repeated updates do not automatically create a wider identity. The wider relation must acquire its own consequence, return, and continuity.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-273 (MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307", "review_ordinal": 146, "source_row_ordinal": 326, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44", "statement": "Claim Manual status --- --- One reality may contain many coexisting patterns Supported structural principle One mind may contain multiple functional identities Supported psychological/architectural principle Identity depends on invariant structure through change Canonical synthesis Coherence requires exact same frequency Rejected Coherence may preserve stable phase difference Supported dynamical principle Ascending/descending are useful continuity directions Formal lens Eternal life requires a higher substrate Theological and continuity hypothesis Higher substrate means greater continuity capacity Architectural definition QFT describes particles as field excitations Established physics framework All electrons share one field-defined particle type Established QFT interpretation All electrons are literally one electron Historical speculative hypothesis The one electron is the observer Unsupported / rejected An electron is a conscious mind Unsupported / rejected Quantum possibility contains many already actual classical electrons Rejected simplification One field–many excitation is a useful identity analogy Supported correspondence lens Substrate transfer proves observer continuation Rejected Recursive realities prove simulation Rejected Many local minds can form a higher mind Conditional architectural hypothesis", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Nested Reality, Fields & Continuity Transfer", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 326, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-007;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-001", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 326, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-307 (MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310", "review_ordinal": 147, "source_row_ordinal": 327, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310", "name": "MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44", "statement": "**A single reality may contain many identities at once, just as one mind may contain many functional roles and one field may support many local excitations. Their coherence does not require exact sameness of frequency or phase. It requires shared invariants, compatible coupling, stable difference, and a continuity band within which local patterns can ascend into differentiated manifestation and descend into integration, return, or renewed expression. Quantum field theory offers a disciplined analogy: many electrons are not best understood as many unrelated classical substances, but as local excitations of one field-defined particle type. Wheeler’s one-electron universe remains a historical speculative picture, not proof that the world is one electron or that an electron is the observer. The continuity question is therefore not whether everything is literally one particle, but whether many local manifestations can preserve one deeper lawful structure—and whether a human identity could ever cross into a higher-capacity substrate without becoming only a copy or losing the first-person point of reference through which its reality is lived.**", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Nested Reality, Fields & Continuity Transfer", "public_page": "identity", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 327, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-007;YT-ID-003;YT-CORE-008;YT-ID-001", "public_page_field": "identity" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 327, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44/MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-007", "claim_title": "Closure, leakage, and recoverability", "claim_status": "Canonical structural synthesis", "claim_guardrail": "Always name the identity, scale, variable, and recovery boundary. Zero leakage is not automatically healthy; local closure can export destructive leakage.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-007" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-003", "claim_title": "Minds within Minds", "claim_status": "Structural derivation and research program", "claim_guardrail": "Containment, proximity, synchronization, or agreement alone does not establish a higher identity. A higher identity alone does not establish distributed observerhood, cognition, or subjective experience.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_05_IDENTITIES_WITHIN_IDENTITIES_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-008", "claim_title": "Existence, persistence, stability, and recoverability are distinct", "claim_status": "Canonical definition set", "claim_guardrail": "Do not use stability, persistence, and recoverability as interchangeable praise words.", "claim_sources": [ "MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46.csv", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_DRAFT_01(103).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-008" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-ID-001", "claim_title": "Identity as history-bearing renewal", "claim_status": "Canonical structural law", "claim_guardrail": "A repeated surface value is not proof of complete identity continuity; the causal path and residue matter.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_04_IDENTITY_AS_A_WAVE_REPAIRED(4).md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-ID-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V44-310 (MANUAL_V2_NESTED_REALITY_SHARED_FIELD_AND_HIGHER_SUBSTRATE_BRIDGE_V44) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006", "review_ordinal": 148, "source_row_ordinal": 328, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006", "name": "MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45", "statement": "It is a localized residue of a deeper structure: a stable, repeatable distinction through which possibility becomes manifest and through which later possibilities are altered.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics, Residue & Consciousness Boundary", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 328, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 328, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-006 (MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061", "review_ordinal": 149, "source_row_ordinal": 329, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061", "name": "MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45", "statement": "text difference → residue → retained residue → memory → interacting memories → recursive comparison → expectation → prediction residue → self/world distinction → integrated point of reference → consciousness candidate", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics, Residue & Consciousness Boundary", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 329, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-DIM-001;YT-COS-001", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 329, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-061 (MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066", "review_ordinal": 150, "source_row_ordinal": 330, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066", "name": "MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45", "statement": "Whether an individual electron has any minimal proto-experiential aspect remains an open philosophical hypothesis. The architecture does not need to assume that an electron is already a complete conscious mind.", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics, Residue & Consciousness Boundary", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 330, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-GEO-003;YT-GEO-002;YT-DIM-001", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 330, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-003", "claim_title": "Geometry does not replace ontology", "claim_status": "Canonical method rule", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer physical shape, sacred necessity, or dimensional count from a convenient diagram.", "claim_sources": [ "THE_STRUCTURE_OF_MIND_CANONICAL_RESTART.md", "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-003" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-DIM-001", "claim_title": "Dimension as consequential non-redundant variation", "claim_status": "Canonical definition", "claim_guardrail": "One value is not a dimension. A temporary combination is not automatically a new dimension.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_08_DIMENSIONS_AND_ATTRIBUTES_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-DIM-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-066 (MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131", "review_ordinal": 151, "source_row_ordinal": 331, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131", "name": "MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45", "statement": "Statement Status in the Manual --- --- A change can leave a residue that alters later change Canonical structural principle Retained residue is necessary for memory Supported structural principle Memory and recursive correction are necessary for mind-like continuity Formal synthesis Electron can be interpreted as a stable localized residue Y-theory correspondence Electron gives possibility by conditioning future interactions Formal/physical correspondence Electron is the complete conscious observer Not established Residue alone is sufficient for consciousness Rejected simplification Consciousness emerges through recursively integrated residue Architectural hypothesis All electrons are one residue-thread Speculative hypothesis The universe is contained inside one electron Rejected One field can express many electron identities Supported field correspondence", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics, Residue & Consciousness Boundary", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-GEO-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 331, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-COS-001;YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-GEO-002", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 331, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-131 (MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } }, { "id": "WMR-BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134", "review_ordinal": 152, "source_row_ordinal": 332, "source_wisdom_id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134", "record_kind": "candidate_wisdom_metadata_review", "current_record": { "id": "BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134", "name": "MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45", "statement": "**The electron should not be imagined as a container inside which all of reality already exists. In the Y interpretation, the wider possibility field comes first. A change within that field leaves a surviving local residue, and when that residue preserves a lawful invariant through later interactions, it becomes an electron identity. The electron is therefore both the residue of prior possibility becoming change and a condition that reshapes future possibility. Residue is the causal seed of consciousness because without retained difference there can be no memory, comparison, expectation, correction, or continuing point of reference. Yet one residue is not by itself the whole of consciousness. Consciousness becomes possible only when residues are retained, related, recursively compared, used to anticipate what comes next, corrected by consequence, and integrated into one continuing observer. The electron may therefore be treated as a primitive residue-node of identity and possibility—not as the whole universe, and not automatically as a complete conscious mind.**", "proof_status": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "normalized_status": "Model bridge / correspondence", "domain": "Physics, Residue & Consciousness Boundary", "public_page": "geometry", "related_claim_ids": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002", "source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "guardrail": "" }, "source_lineage": { "registry_path": "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv", "registry_sha256": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "registry_locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 332, "original_source_field": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "related_claim_ids_field": "YT-CORE-006;YT-CORE-004;YT-COS-001;YT-GEO-002", "public_page_field": "geometry" }, "raw_registry_lineage": { "path": "atlas/MASTER_CANONICAL_WISDOM_REGISTRY_V46_RAW.csv", "sha256": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "locator": "#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134", "csv_data_row_ordinal": 332, "record_state": "exact_baseline_record_match", "exact_match_fields": [ "id", "name", "statement", "proof_status", "source", "guardrail" ], "proof_status_state": "nonblank_in_raw_registry", "guardrail_state": "blank_in_raw_registry" }, "original_source_resolution": { "declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "normalized_declared_source": "MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45/MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45.md", "resolution_state": "not_materialized_in_release_or_inventory", "release_path_exists": false, "inventory_matches": [], "metadata_extraction_authorized": false, "boundary": "Only an exact portable-path match is reported. Basename, lexical, and semantic similarity are not source resolution, and no proof status or guardrail is extracted automatically from a resolved artifact." }, "related_claim_guardrail_contexts": [ { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-006", "claim_title": "Delay, consequence, and residue", "claim_status": "Structural derivation", "claim_guardrail": "Primitive delay is relational order, not yet seconds on a universal clock. Residue is not a full copy or automatically a memory.", "claim_sources": [ "CHAPTER_03_THE_Y_ENGINE_REPAIRED(4).md", "ONE_SOURCE_BOOK_REFINED_NO_LOSS_02.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-006" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-CORE-004", "claim_title": "Source, manifestation, and observer scale", "claim_status": "Canonical distinction", "claim_guardrail": "Possibility is not manifestation, manifestation is not naming, and the observer does not exhaust or arbitrarily create all reality.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "THE MANUAL OF REALITY(8).pdf", "CHAPTER_07_SOURCE_AND_ORDERED_MANIFESTATION_REPAIRED(4).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-CORE-004" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-COS-001", "claim_title": "The universe as containing Mind", "claim_status": "Internally derived structural placement under functional/local observer definition; phenomenal cosmic subject unestablished", "claim_guardrail": "Do not infer a giant human-like personality, universe-wide phenomenal unity, integrated autobiographical memory, intention, agency, or consciousness from containment, local observation, structural consequence-return, or collective science alone.", "claim_sources": [ "PROJECT_REALITY_BRIEF.md", "Book(2).md", "YWP-20260901T005200Z-recursive-triad-and-universe-mind.md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-COS-001" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" }, { "claim_id": "YT-GEO-002", "claim_title": "Toroidal manifestation", "claim_status": "Topological representability theorem under two established bounded coupled cycles", "claim_guardrail": "This proves a topological representation under stated premises. It does not establish the cycles in a target system, a physical toroidal object, a toroidal flow, universal toroidality, or runtime predictive lift.", "claim_sources": [ "Book Prompts Wisdoms(1).md", "Initiation Results(1).md" ], "source_anchor": { "path": "atlas/CANONICAL_CLAIM_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "locator": "#id=YT-GEO-002" }, "application_state": "context_only_not_record_specific_guardrail" } ], "gap_flags": { "original_proof_status_blank": false, "original_proof_status_undeclared": false, "original_proof_status_review_required": false, "guardrail_blank": true }, "proposals": { "original_proof_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "DERIVED_BRIDGE", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134" ] }, "normalized_status": { "state": "retain_current_value_no_change", "value": "Model bridge / correspondence", "review_question": null, "source_locators": [ "atlas/WISDOM_REGISTRY_ENRICHED.csv#id=BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134" ] }, "guardrail": { "state": "unresolved_review_required", "value": null, "review_question": "What precise misuse, overreach, failure condition, or evidence boundary must constrain BR-MANUAL_DOCUMENTATION_INTEGRATION_V45-134 (MANUAL_V2_ELECTRON_AS_RESIDUE_IDENTITY_AND_POSSIBILITY_BRIDGE_V45) before canonical use?", "source_locators": [] } }, "proposition_scoped_correction_boundary": { "correction_head_id": "YWP-20260901T133002Z-relational-coherence-authority", "application_state": "not_semantically_evaluated_review_required", "record_specific_applicability": null, "supersedes_current_metadata": null, "boundary": "The configured relational-coherence author correction is bound to this review build, but record-specific applicability, supersession, wording, proof status, normalized status, and guardrail are not inferred; selection is by declared scope and capture ID, not recency." }, "deterministic_resolution": { "proof_status_resolution_state": "not_a_gap_no_change", "guardrail_resolution_state": "unresolved_no_record_specific_value", "proposed_canonical_proof_status": null, "proposed_canonical_guardrail": null, "related_claim_guardrail_context_count": 4, "related_claim_context_may_be_copied_to_guardrail": false, "canonical_mutation_authorized": false, "proof_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_ORIGINAL_PROOF_STATUS_RETAINED_NO_CHANGE", "DECLARED_ORIGINAL_SOURCE_NOT_MATERIALIZED" ], "guardrail_reason_codes": [ "CURRENT_GUARDRAIL_MISSING", "RAW_REGISTRY_GUARDRAIL_BLANK", "RELATED_CLAIM_GUARDRAILS_ARE_CONTEXT_ONLY", "HUMAN_RECORD_SPECIFIC_GUARDRAIL_REQUIRED" ], "boundary": "Deterministic enrichment exposes exact lineage and contextual claim guardrails; it does not supply either missing canonical value." }, "canonical_approval": { "state": "pending_human_canonical_steward_review", "decision": null, "approved_by": null, "approved_at_utc": null, "notes": null } } ], "input_hashes": { "builder": "7e0cdf0cd3ec9d2ecf974edf85b7653196de1e9015faaa7e54f793a55696f195", "schema": "35c54f1e98a326ba4f7be2298331fcfc4a13af3abf79fac521a83ab8c94ba2d8", "wisdom_registry": "ff9ca7124d566db5c7daef59041a37c46f63a82fb616f88a4b1cef2df5d0f339", "raw_wisdom_registry": "a02ffc1ecd7bc8b9edad09598835453f712d23353e10520f186cdf38d53408ef", "canonical_claim_registry": "879ba7b0eabeeed1e840d24791b7149d921207b7a647aeddd27b6f9914440132", "source_inventory": "0a8ecabf3f140de56987e2b34a18fa91bb75fb523e90bba4ad9bf37cc3595577", "manual_visual_review": "6b29b121e5f9f5ab9b1430a31f9fa8b6a90d69eead3d70de11ae209891cd2f7b", "live_intake": "d53a072bf0c085ab5a7885bd09d78fe53ee69b7dbb89c7da751c41a1e6bc0926" }, "guardrails": [ "Blank and UNDECLARED are review states, never evidence for a stronger proof class.", "A normalized-status label does not fill or prove the original proof_status field.", "A generated review question is not a substantive guardrail and must not be copied into the canonical guardrail field as if approved.", "Nonblank current metadata is preserved exactly and is not re-approved by appearing in this ledger.", "The configured proposition-scoped direct-author correction head is provenance only until record-specific applicability and wording are reviewed.", "Completed visual inspection closes a review obligation only; it supplies no proof status, canonical guardrail, claim validation, or approval.", "Only a human canonical steward may approve a proposed metadata change and mutate the wisdom registry." ] }